ELADIO DIESTE

m us uu q

——————

Trap

S

ELADIO DIESTE Innovation in Structural Art

Stanford Anderson, editor

PRINCETON ARCHITECTURAL PRESS, NEW YORK

Published by

Princeton Architectural Press 3/ East Seventh Street

New York, New York 10003

For a free catalog of books, call 1800.722.6657. Visit our web site at www.papress.com.

© 2004 Princeton Architectural Press All rights reserved

No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner without written permission from the publisher, except in the context of reviews.

Every reasonable attempt has been made to identify owners of copyright. Errors or omissions will be corrected in subsequent editions.

Frontispiece: Eladio Dieste, Church of Christ the Worker, Atlantida, Uruguay, 1958-60. Photograph: Julius Shulman

Support for the Dieste project was significantly provided by the Graham Foundation for Advanced Studies in the Fine Arts, Chicago, and the Batuz Foundation/ Société imaginaire, Altzella, Germany.

Editor: Nancy Eklund Later Associate Editor: Scott Tennent Designer: Jan H aux

Special thanks to: Nettie Aljian, Nicola Bednarek, Janet Behning, Megan Carey, Penny (Yuen Pik) Chu, Russell Fernandez, Clare Jacobson, John King,

Mark Lamster, Linda Lee, Katharine Myers, Jane Sheinman, Jennifer Thompson, Joseph Weston, and Deb Wood of Princeton Architectural Press

—Kevin C. Lippert, publisher

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data:

Eladio Dieste : innovation in structural art / Stanford Anderson, editor. 263 p. : ill. (some col.) ; 31 cm. Includes bibliographical references and index.

ISBN 156898-3/19 (hard cover : alk. paper) l Dieste, Eladio, 191/— Criticism and interpretation. 2. Architecture— Uruguay— 20th century. 3. Architecture— Technological | nnovations—U ruguay. |. Anderson, Stanford. I1. Dieste, Eladio, 1917-

NA929.D5E39 2004 720'.92—dc22 2003023707

el SBN 978-1-61689-002-5

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

INTRODUCTION Stanford Anderson

“DANCE WITH OUT EFFORT OR FATIGUE”: TH E ARCHITECTURE OF ELADIO DIESTE Stanford Anderson

GUASTAVINO, DIESTE, AND THE TWO REVOLUTIONS IN MASONRY VAULTING Edward Allen

ELADIO DIESTE AS STRUCTURAL ARTIST John O chsendorf

TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION IN THE WORK OF ELADIO DIESTE Remo Pedreschi and Gonzalo Larrambebere

42

60

66

76 78 80 86

88 90 94

106 108 109 12 20 124 26 28 156

138

CONTENTS

DIESTE HOUSE, Montevideo, 1961-63 with a description of the house by Antonio Dieste

CHURCH OF CHRIST THE WORKER, Atlántida, 1958-60

CHURCH OF OUR LADY OF LOURDES, M alvín, M ontevideo, 1965-68 (unfinished)

CHURCH OF SAN JUAN DE ÁVILA, ALCALÁ DE HENARES, M adrid, Spain, 1996ff.

CHURCH OF ST. PETER [SAN PEDRO], Durazno, 1969-71

TEM FACTORY, M ontevideo, 1960-62

CEASA PRODUCE MARKET, Porto Alegre, Brazil, 1969-72

CÍTRICOS CAPUTTO FRUIT PACKING PLANT, Salto, 1971-72, 1986-87

LANAS TRINIDAD WOOL INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX, Trinidad, 1965, 1979, 1986-87, 1988-89

RIO METRO MAINTENANCE HANGAR, Rio de Janeiro, 1971-79

MUNICIPAL BUS TERMINAL, Salto, 1973-74

“SEA GULL" (Barbiere and Leggire Service Station), Salto, 1976

AYUÍ PARADOR, Salto, 1976-77

CADYL HORIZONTAL SILO, Young, 1976-78

MASSARO AGROINDU STRIES, Joanicó, Canelones, 1976-80

REFRESCOS DEL NORTE, Salto, 1977-80

SAN AGUSTÍN PARISH CENTER AND GYMNASIUM, M ontevideo, 1978-80 CARUGATTI GARAGE AND WORKSHOP, M ontevideo, 1978-79

PORT WAREH OUSE, Montevideo, 1977-79

TURLIT BUS TERMINAL, Salto, 1980

DIMENSIONS OF A CREATOR: A TRIBUTE TO ELADIO DIESTE Lucio Cáceres

182 191 194

198

202

208

220

223

231

251 255 264

WATER TOWER, Las Vegas Resort, 1966

WATER TOWER, Refrescos del Norte, Salto, 1979

TV COMMUNICATIONS TOWER, Maldonado, 1985-86

DON BOSCO SCHOOL GYMNASIUM, M ontevideo, 1983-84 MONTEVIDEO SHOPPING CENTER, M ontevideo, 1984-85, 1988 FAGAR COLA BOTTLING PLANT, Tarariras, 1991-92, 1995-96 ADF WOOL WAREHOUSE, Juanicó, Canelones, 1992-94 SOLSIRE SALT SILO, M ontevideo, 1992-94

NAVIOS HORIZONTAL SILO, Nueva Palmira, Colonia, 1996-97

APPENDICES

ARCHITECTURE AND CONSTRUCTION THE AWARENESS OF FORM

ART, PEOPLE, TECHNOCRACY

Eladio Dieste

A GRAPHIC PRIMER ON DIESTE'S CONSTRUCTION METHODS Gonzalo Larrambebere

BUILDING CATALAN THIN-TILE VAULTS IN SPAIN: A FIELD JOURNAL Timothy P. Becker and Kent Anderson

RESEARCH AND PRACTICE IN REINFORCED AND PRE-STRESSED BRICKWORK AND THE PLACE OF DIESTE WITHIN IT Remo Pedreschi and Braj Sinha

A PROSPECT FOR STRUCTURAL CERAMICS Antonio Dieste

UNREINFORCED SHELL STRUCTURES IN TRADITIONAL MASONRY: A CONTEMPORARY APPROACH TO DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION M artin Speth

LIST OF WORKS Uruguay Argentina, Brazil, and Spain

BIBLIOGRAPH Y INDEX CONTRIBUTOR BIOGRAPHIES

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This book's beginnings lie in three serendipitous events, unre- lated but almost simultaneous; its publication provides the welcome opportunity to express my deep and continuing grati- tude to several colleagues.

In the fall of 1998, the artist Batuz, founder and leader of the Société imaginaire, an intentionally loose organization in which | participate, asked that | host at Massachusetts | nstitute of Technology a visit by the mayor of Uruguay's capital city, Montevideo, and a number of his colleagues. The mayor, Mariano Arana Sánchez, is an architect and writer on architecture. With our common interests, this was a pleasant meeting but, given the distance between our home cities, might easily have had no further consequence. Batuz was planning a meeting of some members of the Société in Uruguay in November and asked that | join in the activities. Busy with many matters, | did not rush to accept the invitation.

Shortly thereafter, Edward Allen, architect and author, former colleague and long-ti me friend, gave a lecture at MIT on the use of brick in architecture. In a passing note near the end of his presentation, he offered a few slides illustrating the work in reinforced masonry of the U ruguayan engineer Eladio Dieste. | was struck by the invention and beauty of these works. | was also surprised that | knew nothing of them, and that even so well informed a person as Ed could only tempt us with a few copy photographs, never having visited the buildings themselves. | mmediately | knew | had to accept the invitation to visit Uruguay.

| was so importunate as to put a requirement on my participation in the Société imaginaire event: | had to have some time to see the works of Dieste. This agreed, Mayor Arana, who had been a student of Dieste, generously arranged that | beunder the informed guidance of the young architects Salvador Schelotto, an assistant to the mayor; Martín Sales; and Alicia Rodriguez. While we toured some of Dieste's major works, induding both of the famous churches, another plan was unfolding back in Montevideo. A fellow member of the Société, the engineer and Uruguayan Minister of Transport

and Public Works Lucio Cáceres Behrens (also a former stu- dent of Dieste) was arranging for me to meet the architect and engineer. On later visits, Elizabeth Friedheim de Dieste kindly received me at their home— a kindness she extended several times, and one of the many ways in which the Dieste family supported my efforts to learn more about Dieste's career.

The character of the man and his work were so impres- sive that Minister Cáceres and | soon agreed that my interest had to be projected into a concrete enterprise for the apprecia- tion and propagation of knowledge of Eladio Dieste's work. What we conceived was a symposium that would take place both in Montevideo and at MIT. The meetings would of course attend directly to Dieste's projects, but | felt his work should also be seen as a model for other inventions with traditional materials. Preparations for the symposium thus required find- ing not only those who were best informed about the work of Dieste but also those who knew about or had done exploratory work with materials such as wood and stone.

Batuz again supported this significant planning effort. Architects and engineers working on the Dieste symposia gathered within a more general meeting of the Société imagi- naire at Cadenabbia on Lake Como in 1998, with facilities generously provided by the Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung. There, Antonio Dieste, an engineer son of Eladio, and Gonzalo Larrambebere, long the chief associate of Dieste and still the lead engineer for the continuing firm of Dieste y Montañez, entered into the heart of the program. We continued on to the Batuz Foundation headquarters at the monastery of Altzella, near Dresden, for more intense planning sessions. The noted Stuttgart engineer J órg Schlaich joined us, as did the Munich architect Professor Thomas H erzog and architect David Selby of the Michael Hopkins office in London. The result was a preliminary plan for a nine-day excursion, which would take place in late September and early October 2000, beginning in Montevideo with two days of touring Dieste buildings and a two-day symposium, followed by an overnight flight to Boston, a rest day, and a two-day symposium in Cambridge, at MIT.

The symposia successfully cast a conceptual net that reached beyond Dieste's direct accomplishments and brought

together in wonderful camaraderie people from various disci- plines who, for the most part, had not previously known one another. The participants in Montevideo included Edward Allen, Lucio Cáceres, Carlos Clemente (collaborator with Dieste in the late works in Spain), Edward Cullinan (archi- tect, London), Antonio Dieste, Gonzalo Larrambebere, Julius Natterer (noted timber engineer, Lausanne), Yves Pages (architect, Paris), Remo Pedreschi (engineer, U niversity of Edinburgh), Raj Rewal (architect, New Delhi), Peter Ross (engineer, Arup, London), Roland Schweitzer (architect, Paris), Martin Speth (engineer, University of H annover), Mark West (architect, University of Manitoba), and myself. These participants were joined by additional speakers at the MIT symposium: Jórg Schlaich, Antony Smith (engineer, Arup, London), Martin Tschanz (ETH, Zurich), Rafael Viñoly (architect, New York), and Robertson Ward (architect and building technologist, Boston).

The Ministry of Transportation and Public Works and the Batuz Foundation supported the symposium in Montevideo. The ministry handled arrangements, assisted by Martha Kohen of the School of Architecture of the U niversity of the Republic and by an executive committee composed of Nestor Castro, Enrique Benech, and Gonzalo Larrambebere. Rosario Olivero, Graciela | raizóz, Marcelo Dalmases, and Eduardo Rodriguez Briatures provided assistance. Faculty and students of the university mounted an exhibition, with text contributed by Maria E. Yuguero. Nestor Castro of the min- istry and Federico Sanguinetti of the Dieste y Montañez office gave generous and sustained attention to the partici pants.

Planned as an investigation into Eladio Dieste's long and productive career, the Montevideo symposium became rather an homage, after the death of Dieste on July 29, 2000. The Dieste family honored their husband and father, but also their guests, with an evening musical program at Dieste's renowned Church of Christ the Worker in Atlántida.

The Dieste symposia, and in particular the event held at MIT, had many supporters, the most notable of which were the Graham Foundation for Advanced Studies in the Fine Arts; the Arthur H. Schein Memorial Lecture Fund of the

Department of Architecture, MIT; the Piero Belluschi Lecture Fund of the School of Architecture and Planning, MIT; Ove Arup & Partners, London; Rafael Vinoly Architects, New York; the Weyerhaeuser Company Foundation; the Cold Spring Granite Company; the | nternational Masonry Institute; the Aga Khan Program, MIT; Ann Beha Associates, Boston; Ellenzweig Associates, Cambridge, Mass.; and George and Laura H eery of the Brookwood Group, Atlanta. Many of the partici pants donated not only their own time but also their travel costs.

M y assistant Anne Simunovic managed the MIT sym- posium energetically and perfectly. She was ably assisted by a battery of people: from the headquarters of the Department of Architecture, Rebecca Chamberlain, Jack Valleli, and Anne Rhodes; from the MIT student body, Ariel Fausto, Nicole Michel, and Ruth Palmon.

Many people also contributed to the realization of this book, which began as an outgrowth of the symposia but neces- sarily assumed a narrower focus. While | am grateful to all of the contributors, | must give special honor to those who have been constant in the gifts of their knowledge and advice: Edward Allen, Gonzalo Larrambebere (together with his col- leagues Eduardo Dieste and Walter Vilche), Remo Pedreschi, and, most recently, John Ochsendorf. Valeria Koukoutsi Mazarakis was of immense help with images and documenta- tion. The greatest number of the color photographs were taken by Yushihiro Asada and were the product of a campaign conducted in October 2002 together with Jun H ashimoto under the sponsorship of a+u. This Japanese architectural journal generously made these images available for this publi- cation. The photo campaign was organized and guided by Federico Sanguinetti and Marcelo Marrero of Dieste y Montañez. Many of the other excellent images in this book were taken by the Spanish photographer Vicente del Amo Hernández.

In the many labors a book entails, | again drew on my Department of Architecture colleagues Anne Si munovic, Jack Valleli, Anne Rhodes, Donna Beaudry, Joanna Mareth, and Tijana Vujosevic. Nancy Eklund Later has been the

open-minded, demanding, and fulfilling editor for Princeton Architectural Press.

This long list of acknowledgments could only be longer. | must ask the understanding of so many others who have contributed to this enterprise over the years but are not named. It has been very gratifying to receive so much kind assistance from, and now to express my warmest thanks to, the many people who collaborated in a project that came to be very dear to me. | dedicate my efforts in this work to my wife, Nancy Royal.

Stanford Anderson

Rafael Dieste, Obras completas (Sada/ A Coruña, Spain: Ediciós do Castro, 1995), 1/484. English translation by Ann Pendleton-ullian.

Eladio Dieste, in Antonio Jiménez Torrecillas, ed., Eladio Dieste: 1943- 1996 (Seville Consejería de Obras Püblicas y Transportes, 1997), 218.

THE MILLER'S SURPRISE

You built a mill thinking it was only for grinding wheat.

You diverted the water thinking it was only for working the mill.

But the water speaks sentences and couplets never asked for.

And is answered pensi vely, lyrically, by the docile mill.

Building a mill and diverting the water you drew a sign

And, absorbed staring at the ground wheat

you seek to know what it means

—Rafael Dieste

Surprise. As all art, architecture helps us contemplate. Life wears out our ability for surprise. Surpriseis the beginning of atrue vision of the world.

—Eladio Dieste

AFMVD

Carlos Contrera - CMdF

INTRODUCTION Stanford Anderson

Eladio Dieste would not have realized his brilliant, innovative works had he relied on the conventions of ordinary practice; rather, he began from first principles. In the hands of this extraordinary engineer, adherence to first principles did not inhibit but rather enhanced the search for sound forms appropriate to the demands put upon them. It is physically possible to do what is unreasonable, but working from physi- cal principles one is not led to the unreasonable. Brilliant work by a man of principle, revealing a process of designing and building that is principled—this is the legacy of Eladio Dieste. From my first encounter with his work, | knew | wanted to spend more time with it and to ask others to know it better as well.

This book must aspire to be inclusive—inclusive, not as an account of Dieste’s numerous works, or even as an exhaustive account of individual works. Nor should it be an intimate biography that would have to rest in the hands of those who were close to this remarkable man. Rather, it must seek to be indusive in an ambition to recognize the whole- ness of this man and the integral quality of his life and work. Dieste was an engineer—in Spanish, ingeniero. During the last century, the engineering profession allowed that term to lose its sense of the "ingenious." It is to some exemplary individuals that we turn to renew our enthusiasm for inven- tions that are complex yet, once realized, possess a simplicity and seeming inevitability—for inventions that are not mere novelties.

Dieste embraced a techni que— reinforced masonry— that in his day was little known and less exploited. Through that technique he invented appropriate structural types that he employed with daring. H e was a builder. | nnovations in con- struction were necessary and integral to his engineering insights. He built prodigiously, mostly humble structures for storing and making. Yet even these humble works were raised to higher levels; the sheer daring of great spans was part of

this, but only part. In all but the most elemental of these structures other qualities emerge: the proportions of the whole; the economy and elegance of the materials; the detail of the parts; and above all, the knowing use of light as it plays on and especially as it is admitted into these buildings. These are the qualities of a building created by a fine architect. Given only a few (all too rare) special opportunities, Dieste was nonetheless undeniably an architect.

The significance of Dieste's life and work does not end there. H e was born, lived, and predominantly built in U ruguay, a small country of high educational and cultural lev- els but not of generous resources. Diestes choice of materials and the (not exdusively financial) economy of his works systematically address the conditions of his country and potentially those of many under-resourced countries, in an era of superpowers and globalization. Dieste knew full well that resources, wealth, and power are not enough to assure a sound environment or society. Contending with limits may deny many material advantages but not the opportunity to think and contribute substantively to the creation of a fulfilling social state.

Dieste wrote about his engineering innovations and accomplishments, of course. Those accomplishments, how- ever, lay at the core of ever expanding concerns. He was a man of culture. H e understood that art and architecture had been integral to the making of the best buildings and cities of the past and had to be part of any desirable future. Although religion makes little appearance in his writings, Dieste was a man of religion who embraced liberalizing forces within the church. His concerns for social justice and for expanding opportunities for less-resourced people and countries were integral to, and integrated with, his work as an engineer.

This book seeks to illuminate the many facets of a remarkable man. It includes essays by historians, practicing engineers, and architects analyzing Dieste’s work from still more diverse points of view. It even presents a moving tribute to Eladio Dieste and his work by the distinguished figure Lucio Cáceres, minister of transport and public works of the Republic of Uruguay, a former student of Dieste, and family

14

friend of the engineer. But is this only an homage to a man who worked in a very special way under particular circum- stances now vanished? The most recent works illustrated here are less than a decade old, and the firm of Dieste y Montanez continues. Still, even the engineer son Antonio Dieste, in

his reflective essay, raises such questions. The comparati ve economics of several types of construction have shifted, he argues, in both developed and developing countries, mitigating against the conti nued use of reinforced masonry.

Today, the increasing emphasis on sustainability in architecture gi ves cause to continue the considerati on of rein- forced masonry. This building technology employs a material that is local under most circumstances and is remarkably efficient in the use of that material. It has excellent thermal properties. That it is labor-intensive may be altered through innovation, but there are still large parts of the world in which this trait remains an economic and social good. A broader recognition of Dieste's achievements may well suggest continuing opportunities for the use of reinforced masonry construction in certain circumstances— with imagination, perhaps even in situations that at first seem unlikely.

Dieste’s accomplishments inspire thoughts beyond the (albeit deserved) attention to the works themselves and to the conti nued application of his technique. It is stimulating to think that Dieste, with a lifelong devotion that required his mutually reinforcing efforts as engineer, designer, and builder, took such an ancient and elemental material as brick and raised it to unprecedented heights of technical efficiency and aesthetic beauty. The Dieste symposia that marked the begin- nings of this publication attempted to open an inquiry into current and possible innovations with other traditional building materials such as wood and stone. In the case of other “old” building materials, such as glass and fabrics, the materials themselves have gone through radical changes in recent years. The example of Dieste's work may yet serve, in the more general sense, to demonstrate how the integration of abstract thought, design, and making can reinforce one another.

Beyond this integration of conception and making, there is also Dieste's cultural and, indeed, philosophical

understanding, not only of his work but also of his métier and of the contributions of engineers, architects, and artists. If one is not attuned to starting with devoted inquiry into the poten- tials of a particular material or technique, one can do well to consider the higher opportunities and responsibilities advanced by Dieste, and then cycle back to the means for making such contributions. There are ample reasons to come to know Eladio Dieste.

Eladio Dieste Saint Martín was born on December 10, 1917, in Artigas, a town in northern Uruguay on the Brazilian border. His father, also named Eladio, was an atheist who taught his- tory. In 1936, the younger Eladio enrolled in the Faculty of Engineering of the University of the Republic in the capital city of Montevideo, graduating in 1943. The preceding decades had been a time of wealth and growth in Montevideo, still visible today in the fabric of the city and its many fine art deco buildings. In 1944, Dieste, who had accepted the Catholic faith, married Elizabeth Friedheim, a German- ewish immi- grant who converted. The Diestes had twelve children, one of whom died in infancy!

From 1944 to 1947, Dieste worked as an engineer on bridge projects for the Highway Administration of the Uruguayan Ministry of Public Works. For the same ministry he was made head of the technical section of the Architecture Office from 1945 to 1948. In these years he was also associated with the Norwegian contractors Christiane & Nielsen. Between 1949 and 1958, he was the directing engineer for the Viermond piling company. In addition, from 1945 on, Dieste also taught mechanics at the Faculty of Engineering.

In 1946 Dieste realized his first reinforced brick vault while collaborating with the Catalan architect Antoní Bonet on the Berlingieri house in Punta Ballena.? In 1956, Dieste and Eugenio Montañez (1916-2001), a fellow graduate of the uni- versity, founded the firm of Dieste y Montañez, S.A., through which their great body of work was accomplished. A strong reason for the success of the firm in realizing unprecedented works is that this was a construction as well as design firm. Both of these activities significantly informed the other,

encouraging progressi ve development of the firms concepts and efficient production. Dieste and his followers are keen to point out that the firm was able to carry out large amounts

of what we see as innovative and creative work because it could perform competitively while offering alternative building techniques.

As the firm was engaged in projects from concept to the laying of bricks, many people contributed to its success. Most important was Dieste's partner, Montañez—a balancing figure, astute in the organization of work and the development of the company. The firm began consulting work in Brazil in the 1960s. Early in the 1970s, Montañez moved to Brazil; he took responsibility for massive projects there, including construction by Dieste y Montañez, until his return to Montevideo at the end of the decade. The engineers Raúl Romero, Gonzalo Larrambebere, Ariel Valmaggia, and José M. Zorrilla, the technical assistant Walter Vilche, and the archi- tect Alberto Castro sustained long-term collaborative relati on- ships with the firm. Dieste's son Eduardo continues in its management, and the names of other sons—the engineer Antonio and the architect Esteban— appear in the credits for numerous works.

The high level of craftsmanship exhibited by the firms work was only possible with a stable crew of expert workers on the building site. The most frequently mentioned of these is

l Biographical information on Eladio Dieste is owing to several souces, induding personal communications from his son Antonio and members of the firm of Dieste y Montañez; also from Antonio Jiménez Torrecillas, ed., Eladio Dieste 1943-1996, trans. Michael Maloy and Harold David Kornegay (Seville: Consehería de Obras Püblicas y Transportes, 1997).

All projects discussed in this volume were built in Uruguay, unless otherwise noted. 2 For more on this project, see} ohn Ochsendorf's essay on pages 96-97 of this volume.

the mason Vittorio Vergalito, who spent thirty-eight years with Dieste y Montañez; Edio Vito Pacheco and Alberto Hernandez devoted thirty-six and thirty years, respectively. Eduardo Dieste wrote movingly of these men. Of Vergalito, he said, "To my father, Vittorio is the evidence of what he feels to be the truth. Heis the person who best incarnates the philosophy on which his whole work is based."? The most commonly mentioned architect collaborator is Alberto Castro, who worked with Dieste on numerous projects, including the Church of St. Peter in Durazno. In a personal communication, Castro assures that the engineers and architects of the Dieste office were truly collaborators but under the "natural leadership of an exceptional man, Eladio Dieste."4

Dieste was a corresponding member of the Academy of Sciences of Argentina, honorary professor of the schools of architecture of Montevideo and Buenos Aires, and a member of the Uruguayan Academy of Engineers. H e received the Gabriela Mistral Award of the Organization of American States in 1990, the Americas Award in 1991, and an honorary professorship from the University of the Republic in 1993,

Beginning in 1993, Dieste collaborated with the archi- tects Carlos Clemente and Juan de Dios de la H oz on a "Students Street” for the University of Alcalá near Madrid, Spain, and on three churches in the same area, each modeled on one of the noted churches he had designed in Uruguay. Dieste continued this association despite a degenerati ve disease that after 1995 left him confined to his home. Eladio Dieste died on July 29, 2000, in Montevideo. His gentle, accommodating wife still resides in the home he built over- looking the River Plate. The firm of Dieste y Montanez continues today and has been instrumental in the realization of this book; it is represented here in the contributions of the engineer Gonzalo Larrambebere and in many other details.

The first small book on Eladio Dieste was written by the Argentine architect and historian Juan Pablo Bonta. Published in 1963 it included the Church of Christ the Worker at Atlántida and the Dieste house. Indeed, the attention gi ven to these works, rather than the more characteristic warehouses

16

and industrial buildings, is a sign that Dieste had already become a figure in the world of architecture. The bibliography of Bonta's book suggests that the new appreciation of Dieste as architect was, at that time, stronger internationally than in Uruguay. Subsequent extensive (primarily journal) literature by and about Dieste originated almost wholly from South America and Europe. Two monographs— one edited by Antonio Jiménez in Spain in 1996 and the other by Remo Pedreschi in Britain in 2000— never lose sight of Dieste the architect but are organized around the structural typologies found in his work.” Despite these recent monographs, the name Eladio Dieste remains remarkably obscure in North America—a failing the MIT symposium of 2000 and this book seek to alter.

What then is the envisioned role of this book? Above all, it looks to the architecture of Eladio Dieste. Early and spe- Cial attention is given to the Dieste house and the two famous churches in Atlántida and Durazno. The architectural qualities of a broad range of Dieste's production are also emphasized. This is particularly the role of my essay but is reinforced in distinct ways by Remo Pedreschi and Gonzalo Larrambebere and by John Ochsendorf as well.

This book also provides a historical dimension to the study of Dieste, in at least four ways. Dieste's body of work is arrayed in near chronological order in the project portfolio disbursed throughout the volume. This is designed to invite easier consideration of the development of his oeuvre.

Historical context is also provided in a number of essays contained herein. Edward Allen provides a brief overview of the major types of compressive masonry vaults from antiquity to the present day, giving careful attention to the impressive lightweight vaults built without formwork in Catalonia and to the extraordinary elaboration of this tech- nique in the work, mainly in the United States, of the Catalan architect Rafael Guastavino. Knowledge of this history is rewarding in itself and necessary if one is to understand the unique contribution of Dieste's vaulting techniques.

John Ochsendorf places Dieste's work in the context of "structural art." Eduardo Torroja, Eugene Freyssinet, Robert

Maillart, and Heinz Isler are among those noted engineers who have been seen to change our visual culture not only with the technical innovations of their work but also with their coherent aesthetic production. The author gives a fresh assess- ment of Diestes accomplishments by comparing his work with that of these other four masters of structural art.

Remo Pedreschi and his colleague Braj Sinha provide our fourth historical account in the appendix of this volume: a thorough review of the literature on reinforced masonry.

In his essay that appears earlier in this book, and with the collaboration of Gonzalo Larrambebere, Pedreschi turns the tables on his own monograph, which was constructed to reveal how the engineer has contributed to contemporary architecture. In this volume, conceived by an architect and built around architecture, Pedreschi's role is to draw due attention to Dieste's technical contributions in the areas of structure and construction.

The argument of the book as outlined here is supple- mented by extensive appendices. As previously noted, Eladio Dieste was a profound and socially committed thinker. We reproduce three of his essays here. Timothy P. Becker and Kent Anderson's firsthand description of Catalan vaulting nicely supplements Allen's essay. Antonio Dieste makes the argument that his father's work can have continued life only if technical innovation in reinforced masonry continues,

3 Eduardo Dieste to Antonio Jiménez Torrecillas, August 1998, quoted in Pedreschi, Eladio Dieste, The Engineer's Contribution to Contemporary Architecture (London: Thomas Telford, 2000), 19. 4 SeeAndersons essay, 38, n. 14. of this volume. It should be noted that many of the Dieste projects included subsidiary buildings, office components, and the like that required architectural design and were presumably rarely the province of Dieste himself. 5 Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste. This book is beautifully produced, with fine illustrations and much information by and about Eladio Dieste. It also has a small supplementary technical volume. It is a fundamental resource for the study of Dieste.

Pedreschi, Eladio Dieste. The engineer Pedreschi precisely lives up to the series title in which his book appeared, The Engineer's Contribution to Contemporary Architecture It is not surprising then

perhaps in unanticipated ways. Finally the young German engineer Martin Speth draws inspiration from Eladio Dieste's work but finds reason, under the industrialized conditions of his country, to explore prefabricated but unreinforced masonry vaults— not the projection Antonio Dieste sets out but fulfilling one of his expectations, being unantici pated.

To this volume there is another, already somewhat revealed, agenda. At a time when we are encouraged to embrace the idea that digital technologies allow not only the representation but also the physical realization of absolutely any form,

for any or no reason, | invite the reader to exercise critical discrimination— between novelties and profound, complex, and responsible innovations, as Eladio Dieste sought and often realized.

that the author has been an important resource and collaborator in the production of the current book.

17

fig. 1

DIESTE HOUSE

M ontevi deo, 1961- 1963

The house Dieste built for himself and his family occupies most of its small site. Three terrace and courtyard areas provide varied associations of exterior and inte- rior for both the public and private spaces of the house. Small self-carrying (or “freestanding”) vaults are used throughout, except in the kitchen, corridor, and lower floor areas, where reinforced masonry slabs are used. The vaults provide a sense of release in the small bedrooms and study but also open laterally between rooms and longitudinally, with openwork forming a pergola, into the courtyard.

fig. E

fig. 2:

oS

Dieste H ouse, Montevideo, 1961-63. Street facade with garage and entry below the front garden terrace

(top) Transverse sections through the family room, entrance stair, and study (a-a); courtyard-terrace, dining area, kitchen, and hall (b-b); and bedrooms (c-c)

(center) Longitudinal section through garden-terrace, entrance, dining area, courtyard, "veranda," a children's bedroom, and rear garden (d-d)

(bottom) Lower floor plans and main floor plans

CORTE a-a

PLANTA ALTA

[a y

PLANTA BAJA

AS کک جج‎ 2 er

CORTE b-b

CORTE t-t

CORTE d.d

THE DIESTE HOUSE Antonio Dieste

Located on one of M ontevideos high grounds, approximately 100 feet from the shore of the River Plate ("the river wide as the sea"), the Dieste H ouse frames views of the water over its neighbors rooftops. M y father, Eladio Dieste, bought the property in 1952. For financial reasons, construction of the house was delayed until 1961, and the house was completed in 1963.

The site is long and narrow. M y father had a clear vision of how the house should occupy the terrain. | t was designed to provide the largest possible number of rooms with openings to the

north and east, clustered around two patios. The windows facing north are surmounted by awnings or gazebos, covered by a decid- uous dimber, that allow sunlight to enter the rooms in winter and provide shade in the summer.

From the entrance, above the street but below the main body of the house, a staircase leads up to the dining room and family room, each a separate but open space facing both the garden-terrace at the front and the inner courtyard, with its brick benches built into the walls.

The garden-terrace opens to the sea. From the study, the view is framed by the terrace parapet, designed as an opening in the wall. From his seat at the head of the dining table, my father

fig. 3

fig. 33 View from near the entrance to the upper terrace fig. 4: Stairs from front entry to the central point of the house fig. 5: View from top of entry stairs to the central courtyard

fig. 4

fig. 5

fig. 6

Raised garden-terrace at the front of the house. To the right, the family room doors

Window and opening in terrace wall

Dining area with window and wall opening aligned to the sea. To

the left, the family room View past the entrance stair and dining area to the family room

could see the outlines of ships on the horizon through the main staircase window and an opening in the garden-terrace wall. Today, this view is blocked by a pine tree.

The house appears totally hermetic from the outside, though it is ample within. People walking down the street cannot see into the house except to the garden-terrace. Even there, one may find corners where it is possibleto sit and read quietly or enjoy the autumn sun, protected from the outside view. This gives the house a sense of mystery that may have a disquieting effect on passersby.

The house was home to a large family: our parents, eleven children, and a maid. On the upper floor, my parents bedroom

fig. 8

fig. 9

and two additional bedrooms— one for the three younger boys and another for the four girls— face the veranda on the far side of the central patio. The children used the veranda, overlooking the patio, as a place to do their homework. It was also used as

a sewing room. The elder boys bedroom was on the lower level and opened to an "English patio," a very self-contained area next to a study.

By thetime Dieste started working at home, because of health reasons, all the children had left the house. H e first used the elder boys bedroom as his workplace When he could no longer use the stairs, he worked on the veranda on the upper floor. |t was here where he worked on the Spanish projects in the late 1990s.

D ¡este justified the use of reinforced ceramic vaults and there, by a north-facing window, enjoying the sun. In the bed-

load-bearing walls— the characteristic elements of his work— as rooms, small light niches reveal the depth of the wall. The seasonal structural elements. H ere, however, the formal effects of the and hourly positions of the sun can be traced through the chang- vaults prevail over structural reasoning, as the spans involved ing color spots cast on the floor and the adjacent walls. A metal in building the house are within the range of more economical fireplace set into the study wall provides the primitive pleasure of concrete slabs. watching a fire.

The notable thickness of the walls is the result of both A stereo system is housed in the wall separating the dining formal and functional considerations. Throughout the house, the room from the living room. The equipment, consisting of a radio walls contain boxes for roller-blinds and built-in bookshelves. and a record player, is placed behind wooden doors, and the Vents for the central heating system open through holes cut in the speakers are covered with rattan panels. M y father had very set wooden lids of the window sills. In the living room the walls also views regarding our education. We had a radio at home but no serve as seats. On a winter afternoon, it is very pleasant to sit television. H e only allowed us to listen to the National Radio

-] ge mur T a um um "iL

uil E^ e

sax Y i e v. "Hs PE i a." = L

— 0

S ID a

1 b. La

Lr: MER. En 4

LT m "n ia

fig. 10

24

fig. 10: The secluded house, viewed from the street fig. 1: View from the front through the family room to the courtyard, with the raised dining area to the left

fig. 11

25

fig. 12: "Veranda," a gallery giving access to the bedrooms and with a view to the central courtyard

fig. 13: View from the family room to the central courtyard. Note the openwork brick vault with its climber moderating the light on the paved terrace slightly above the courtyard itself.

fig. 14: Dieste's study, looking to the raised hard terrace at the front of

the house

fig. Y

E

tea NH. r3

2 Y

کے

fig. 13

26

Broadcasting Service, which only aired classical music and the news. |f he arrived home to find us listening to anything else he simply said, "National Broadcasting," emphasizing each word. With that, we would have to return to Prokofievs Peter and the Wolf or Bach's Brandenburg concerti.

In Uruguay, television transmission began in the mid- 1950s. For many years (until 1982), Diestes house was the only one in the neighborhood without a TV set. M y father considered television culturally negative and the TV set itself aesthetically unappealing. Nor were comics allowed in the house (though we managed to obtain and hide them). We did have books, by the likes of H ans Christian Andersen, the Brothers Grimm, and

fig. 14

H oracio Quiroga. There was Twain's Tom Sawyer, Stevenson's Treasure Island, M elvilles Moby-Dick and books by Dickens, Kipling, and Dumas that we received as birthday presents or as presents on the sixth of January (a Spanish tradition, in which children receive gifts from the Three Wise M en as Jesus did). As time went by and we grew older, we could read from the vast bookcase, where we could find almost anything. Whatever we could not find, we could ask for; we could be denied a pair of new shoes but never a book. M oney was no issue when it came to books.

Dieste always refused to have decorative elements in the house. Over the years, he only agreed to incorporate the following

fig. 15: View from the arrival point through the dining area to the family room and court. The table was designed by Dieste.

fig. 16: View of the family room and the dining area. Eladio Dieste, visible through the central window

fig. 15

28

fig. 16

objects: a painting and a small sculpture by J oaquín Torres García; two Eduardo Yepes sculptures ( Christ on the Cross and TheVirgin); a copy of an Egyptian cat; two glass art pieces by Agueda Dicancro; two sculptures by my brother Eduardo (a woodcut of a hake and a mechanical contraption devised by my father himself, rescued from the junkyard by Eduardo and set on a wooden stand); a woodcut of a Franciscan by an unknown artist; and a scale model of a sailing boat. Thelast two were only partially accepted by Dieste; they were placed so that he could not see them from where he normally sat.

This rejection of ornament was not a whim. In my father's architecture there are carefully proportioned volumes and surfaces,

both curved and flat, that form spaces we inhabit and that interact with light. H e believed that decorative elements become obstacles to our understanding the essential.

Each piece of furniture has a precise and defined location. For instance, in the bedroom a recess is carved in the wall behind the bedstead and fitted with a white acrylic panel, a reading light, and a small bookshelf. The rigidity in thelocation of the beds created a problem, following the adoption of the final scheme for the building, when my youngest sister was born and an additional bed was required. The formal disturbance this caused was only resolved when one of my sisters got married and left the family home.

29

Dieste designed most of the furniture in the house. The breakfast tableis an extreme example of a site-specific piece of furniture. Its single leg, which secures the entire table and eight stools, is built into the floor slab.

After my father's death, | visited a monastery in the city of Tomar in Portugal, the headquarters of the Order of Christ Templars, built in the twelfth century. In the monastery there is a window from the sixteenth century, reputed to be the most stunning example of M anuelina decoration. | n contrast to this window, in each of the monk-knights cells thereis a window seat made of a simple stone slab set within the width of the wall.

The white walls of the bedrooms have no decorative elements. The

fig. 17

bareness of these cells is the fruit of a religious conviction that ornament is a trick of the devil, used to drive us away from God.

| am surethat my father would have spent more time in contemplation of the cells than on the famous window. | can imagine him in the cloister, in spiritual communion with the monks who lived there centuries ago.

fig. 17: One of the Dieste children's bedrooms

fig. 18: Built-in single-legged kitchen dining table

fig. 19: View from the court through the family room to the front terrace

fig. 20: Rear facade. Note the distinction of the structural vault from the upper profile of the roof.

fig. 20

fig. 19

E pa

FRE =

“DANCE WITH OUT EFFORT OR FATIGUE”: TH E ARCHITECTURE OF ELADIO DIESTE Stanford Anderson

"A lightness, a mysterious ease, a concise simplicity some- thing like dance without effort or fatigue": these are words that Eladio Dieste used to describe the goals for his work. Such were the necessary conditions, he argued, for convinced acceptance of a building by its users.

Dieste wrote those words out of the specific concern that his work should communicate with ordinary people. In the same essay “Art, People, Technocracy,” he tells of his expe- rience of a humble woman with coarse shoes covered in mud at his Church of Christ the Worker in the village of Atlántida: "Theitinerary that she followed, the places where she paused, the things that she said with complete simplicity and without accolades: these things that made me realize she was really seeing it.”2 Dieste assures us this was not a singular experi- ence. He was certain that people are not moved when a diffi- culty is resolved by brute force but rather want to perceive a problem resolved with the effortlessness of a hawk soaring in the sky or a flower unfolding in the sun. It is onething to have such an ethereal ambition and quite another to achieve it. Yet that is what Dieste achieved in his buildings. It is no accident that the phrase "light as a brick" was invented for his work.? The buildings of this master and innovator of rein- forced brick construction address us so effortlessly, and ye forcefully, that a brief first exposure suffices to assure a deep engagement.

Theinexplicable neglect in North America of Eladio Dieste accounts for the fact that my own exposure to his work came late in a long career involved with modern architecture and then, incidentally. In 1998 | received an unanticipated invitation to visit Uruguay, followed a few days later by a coinci- dental, brief exposure to two or three images of Dieste's build- ings. One incident informed the other; soon | found myself touring the work of Dieste and then taken to visit the engineer at his home by one of his former students, Lucio Caceres, a civil engineer and the Minister of Public Works of Uruguay.

2

fig. 2E “Sea Gull" (originally the Barbiere and Leggire Service Station), Salto, 1976. Dieste's Refrescos del Norte complex appears in the distance.

fig. 22: Massaro Agroindustries, Joanicó, Canelones, 1976-80. This view is taken from the five-vaulted main sheds to the three double- cantilever, self-carrying vaults at the entry.

fig. 23: Port Warehouse, Montevideo, 1977-79. Note the double-curvature, or “Gaussian,” vaults and detail at an end wall.

| nserted into this meeting of friends, | was soon able to reveal, in effect, my own conviction about Dieste's work as a "dance without effort or fati gue"—though these were words | had not yet had occasion to learn. As genuine and motivated as were my first words to Dieste, perhaps | was too enthusiastic in my appreciation. Though suffering the effects of a degener- ative disease, Dieste, with a knowing and friendly sparkle in his eyes, calmed me with the words: "| too obey the laws of physi cs!"

In the presence of Dieste's buildings, one may some- times wonder if he truly obeyed those laws. But, yes, he was an engineer, and there the buildings stand. The laws of physics are satisfied. Nonetheless, we must also observe that there is all the difference in the world between engineering work that remains safely controlled within the conventions of ordinary practice and that which challenges convention. Dieste imagined new possibilities and then, yes, observed only the laws of physics, not standard practice, both as a critic and a facilitator. Additionally, it must be emphasized that Dieste's innovations are not for the sake of novelty They are rather the result of a continuous quest, a reasoned approach to building well, addressing the pragmatic problems at hand but also sat- isfying his own profound demands, ethical and spiritual, that lay behind his dance.

Dieste made himself the master of reinforced ceramics, virtu- ally the only mode in which he built. The vast majority of his structures serve everyday purposes of work and storage. He invented two distinctive forms of reinforced brick vaulting that were instrumental in winning the economic competition to build these utilitarian structures. Serving pragmatic purposes and doing so economically (in terms of time and cost) was the fundamental business model of the engineering firm of Dieste y Montañez. It is not despite these constraints but largely because of them that these buildings rise above their quotidian settings and achieve an ennobling architectural presence.

Of Dieste's two major innovations in structural types in reinforced brick masonry, consider first what he termed "self- carrying vaults." These are barrel vaults with none of the usual

fig. 21

fig. 22

conditions of support for such a vault: no continuous side wall supports or buttresses, no tympanum or arch under the vault at its ends. Dieste's vaults rest on columns—or even a single column (fig. 2! Less demonstrative but equally impressive are the true self-carrying vaults whose basic variants are well illustrated by the sheds for Massaro Agroindustries. The main storage area is formed by a set of five parallel barrel vaults carried on a sparse grid of columns, with a cantilever of 54 feet at one end. Freely sliding under that cantilever are three still more astounding vaults with 43-foot cantilevers in both directions, carried on a single row of four columns (fig. 22).

Such minimal support is only possible, of course, if the vault, unlike traditional masonry vaults, can resist bending forces. This Dieste accomplishes by introducing pre-stressing steel that pre-compresses the vault. | n cross section, the vaults are given the most effective structural form—a catenary. This, together with ordinary reinforcing bars between rows of bricks, yields a thin and light vault. This lightness reduces the lateral forces but, of course, the forces are there and must be counteracted. Dieste's characteristic elegant solution is a hori- zontal edge beam at the outer limit of any group of vaults—a beam that collects the lateral forces and brings them back to vertical buttresses at point supports. In the long direction of a barrel vault supported on columns, the vault acts as a beam, and itis here that the pre-stressing becomes necessary. Atop the brick masonry, successive loops of steel are tensed and then imbedded in a thin concrete layer, applying high com- pressive forces to resist tension in the finished vault. In these self-carrying vaults, the few and distant points of support and the thin, unsupported ends of the vaults convey directly the seemingly effortless lightness of these constructions.

Dieste’s second major structural innovation was in what he termed "Gaussian" double-curvature vaults. Barrel vaults rise high in relation to their transverse span and thus are not well suited to broad spans. H owever, a thin vault of long span and low rise is susceptible to buckling and thus not sound structurally. Dieste gave strength to such vaults not by making the vault more massive (a solution by brute force that he naturally resisted) but by making the vault in successive

fig. 23

transverse bands, each of which was given a greatly increased bending stiffness by means of three-dimensional curvature. At the center of the span where the forces to be resisted are greatest, the band has as its cross section (in the longitudinal direction of the building) a reclining s-shape (fig. 23).? Dieste configured the s-shape to be lower and flatter at one side than at the other; when such bands of vault are built next to one another, the disparity of the edges of the neighboring s-shapes leaves a long, curving lunette ideal for illumination at frequent intervals and across the width of the building. Because the vaults are carried on edge beams, Dieste often introduced continuous windows in the walls below the beams. Recurrentl y, Dieste framed these glazed openings with the simplest of small steel bars. Ever attentive to simplified systems of support, he progressively flattened the full s-shape of mid-span until the vault became a continuous horizontal line at its outer supports. The long span and low rise of these Gaussian vaults result in significant lateral thrusts that were usually resolved with exposed horizontal tie-bars, though Dieste had no love for them. By extending the columns of the Don Bosco school gymnasium in Montevideo, he succeeded in placing the ties above the roof where they are effectively invisible from within. In a variant of the Gaussian vault used in his horizontal silos, where a higher pitched vault reaches the ground, Dieste absorbed the horizontal thrust in the floor or foundation.

1 Eladio Dieste, “Art, People, Technocracy,” 194 of this volume. Originally published as “Arte, pueblo, tecnocracía,” in Eladio Dieste: La estructura cerámica, ed. Galaor Carbonell, Colección Somosur (Bogotá, Colombia: Escala, 1987).

2 Ibid.

3 Juan Martín Piaggio, Leggero come un mattone: L'Architettura de Eladio Dieste (Parma, Italy: Industria Leterizi Giavarini S.p.A., 1997).

4 The“Sea Gull” is not, strictly speaking, a vault since the cross section cannot act in compression. Its form and construction do, however, owe much to Dieste's self-carrying vaults.

5 There are also those constructions, as at the church at Atlántida, where the Gaussian vaults are a continuous surface, at times penetrated to provide light.

That Dieste built with brick is one of the reasons for his neglect in architectural history and criticism. His career coincided with the prominence of theories of architecture and its history that embraced dubious notions of a modern zeit- geist. An inevitable evolution toward a technologically advanced society demanded, it was said, the use in architecture of "modern materials" such as steel, concrete, and glass. Dieste was educated in the emerging practices of framing and vaulting with reinforced concrete, yet he chose to build in brick. While his innovative brick structures grew out of precedents and practice in reinforced concrete, Dieste quite reasonably argued that new materials do not necessarily displace earlier materials of demonstrated effecti veness.

Dieste found compelling reasons for the use of ceramic materials in the marginalized economy of Uruguay. H owever, he also supported brick construction for reasons that rely only partially on that local condition. He claimed advantages for brick over concrete, including relative strength for weight, better resistance to temperature changes and aging, better acoustic and environmental qualities, and, in comparable quality, lower costó In this Dieste provided good, hardheaded reasons for preferring to work in brick. Further, he believed that the tectonic sense of a durable material with agreeable qualities of color and texture, worked with sound craftsman- shi p, had a general appeal.

A claim for the architectural quality of Dieste's utili- tarian buildings, however, goes beyond both the performance characteristics and agreeable qualities of brick. Dieste's effortless dance relies, of course, on the structural innova- tions we have rehearsed, but belief in the dance relies on the intrinsic architectural quality of his achievement. |n those buildings of a single volume, the space is generous and well proportioned; the structure itself is articulated in smaller ele- ments, down to the handheld, often handmade, brick itself. In the buildings of multiple bays, both the clarity of each bay and the associations among them offer compelling spatial experiences. When, as at Massaro, impressive cantilevers overhang one another, there is a wonderful sequencing of open to covered and finally enclosed spaces. Another aspect

3

of this sequencing is natural light. The self-carrying vaults admit light where they overlap or stop short of one another, or where they are simply penetrated. The Gaussian vaults yield very special qualities of light. In addition to the effec- tive dispersion of light throughout these buildings, there is the virtually sentient way in which different aspects of the vaults are revealed as one moves beneath them. From one direction, there is the soft lighting over the curving surfaces of the vaults; from the other, the repetition of the glazed lunettes with views of the sky. The last vault at either end of the series poses here the lower, flatter arch, and there the higher arch of either side of the s-shaped vault section. Characteristically, Dieste demonstrates the difference of the two ends of the series of vaults with different heights of glazing above the opposite end walls. That glazing also allows emphasis of the thin end of the vault and the absence of a tympanum or other structural support.

We know there are buildings that are technically sound with- out becoming architecture. And there are buildings of widely recognized architectural standing that are open to technical and tectonic criticism. There remains a special place for tech- nically sound buildings that achieve high tectonic standards and thus deserve to be recognized as architecture. This is all the more true when the designers of these buildings also ran the risks inherent in technical and tectonic innovation. Dieste successfully took such risks. His are works that do not indulge the arbitrary, works in which the form of the structure is also the form of the building and the delimiter of space. Dieste stated this more strictly:

A building cannot be profound as a work of art unless it has

an earnest and subtle fidelity to the laws of matter. Only the

reverence that this fidelity requires can make our buildings

serious, lasting, and worthy partners in our contemplati ve

journey.’ The utter directness of Diestes work—its "earnest and subtle fidelity to the laws of matter”— moves us.

Within his oeuvre and beyond the types of buildings already mentioned are a few works that are especially integral

to Dieste's contemplative journey. Dieste’s best-known work is the Church of Christ the Worker in Atlántida. It is all the more remarkable for having been created early in his career. It is both proof of Dieste's architectural capacity from the outset and an inventive variation on the system of Gaussian vaults.

A detailed discussion of this impressive structure can be found in the essays of John Ochsendorf and Remo Pedreschi contained in this volume.

The Dieste H ouse in Montevideo, built between 1961 and 1963 is located on a street that parallels the River Plate.8 The house rests on steeply rising ground on the landward side of the street, providing a view south to the sea. The house with its courtyards occupies most of a narrow but deep lot, as was necessary for a large family of eleven children, even if the accommodations are economically organized.

The driveway makes a steep ascent to a broad terrace that is both carport and entry to the lower level of the house. The entrance is compact but ascends immediately via an L-shaped stair to the living room, built on grade less than a full story above. The living room is truly the center of the house and possesses varied and excellent relations to the exterior. To the south is a two-level open space, planted as it extends from the living room; and a hard-surfaced, partially covered terrace, which forms a roof over the entrance. To the north (which here, in the Southern H emisphere, is the direction of the sun)

6 Thefull list of advantages appears in Antonio Jiménez Torrecillas, ed., Eladio Dieste 1943- 1996, trans. Michael Maloy and Harold David Kornegay (Seville: Consejería de Obras Püblicas y Transportes, 1997), 34-36. This list, lacking a final point on low cost, first appeared in Eladio Dieste, "Acerca de la cerámica armada," Summa (Buenos Aires) 70 (Dec. 1973). It is considered more fully here in John Ochsendorf's essay on page 103 of this volume.

7 Eladio Dieste, "Architecture and Construction,” 188 of this volume. Originally published as "Arquitectura y construcción,” in “Eladio Dieste, el Maestro del Ladrillo,” sp. no., Summa: Colección Summarios (Buenos Aires) 8, no. 45 (July 1980): 84-93

8 An essay by Antonio Dieste, one of Eladio Dieste's sons and himself a civil engineer, provides a description of the family home and insights that only a family member could give. See 18-31 of this volume.

is a constructed terrace under an openwork brick vault that opens to a generous courtyard garden.

Back in the living room, three steps bring one up to the dining space that is continuous with the living room except for the low storage units that further define the change of level between the two areas. This main level of the house is roofed with self-carrying vaults of a small span. Even at this scale, these vaults fulfill most of the claims Dieste had made for brick construction.? They serve important architectural pur- poses as well. The continuity of the living and dining areas is also articulated with their separate vaults. These main spaces of the house, with their undulating vaults, achieve both an intimacy and a generosity that no flat ceiling, high or low, would offer. From the living room to the sunny courtyard, the vault first offers a high, protected source of balanced light, beyond which is the perforated vault of the terrace that nuances the light both of the terrace and the interior. The shape and the percei ved warmth of the vaults significantly ease the compactness of smaller spaces like the bedrooms and Dieste's study. V

There is reason to suppose that Dieste knew of Le Corbusier's famed Jaoul houses, built between 1954 and 1956 in Neuilly, outside Paris, which use walls of brick and thin-tile vaults. The structures are, however, very different than Diestes. The vaults of the Jaoul houses are not reinforced and

9 Antonio Dieste notes that these spans could have been achieved more efficiently and economically with prefabricated concrete slabs. Of course here Dieste was not in economic competition for the commission, but nei- ther was he merely advertising his business of building vaults.

10 Dieste's sense for the making of domestic space is revealed in his story of his encounter with an elderly woman in her humble, but humane and beautiful, room. See Dieste, “Art, People, Technocracy” 196 of this volume. ll Aside from the renown of Le Corbusier and the J aoul houses, Dieste, through the design of his first reinforced brick vaults for the Berlingieri house in 1946, had early association with the Catalan architect Antoní Bonet, who had moved in the cirde of Josep Lluis Sert and Le Corbusier. See Ochsendorf's essay on page 96 of this volume.

fig. 24: Church of St. Peter [San Pedro], Durazno, 1969-71, axonometric section

fig. 25: Church of St. Peter, axial view from the nave to the sanctuary

fig. 26: Church of St. Peter, axial view from the nave to the rose window over the narthex

fig. 27: Church of St. Peter, view up into the light tower of the sanctuary

fig. 28: Church of St. Peter, angle view from the west side aisle to the sanctuary

thus span between heavy walls or concrete beams and employ exposed tie-rods. The structural system is conventional and strongly cellular in its definition of space. The materials of the two houses suggest a relation, but Dieste's structural innova- tions opened new architectural potentials that he realized.

Beyond such claims for the vaulting, the architectural achievement of the Dieste H ouse also rests on the compelling organization of the site and the house. The positive potential of the sloping site is realized. The changes of level, the several special relations of house and garden, the knowing use of light, and— employing all of these features and more—the appropriate distinctions of public and private are all the marks of afully realized architectural proposition.

The most uncharacteristic work by Dieste is also the most subtle architectural achievement of his career: the Church of St. Peter in the provincial city of Durazno. The task at hand may well have seemed unpromising at first. In 1967, the origi- nal timber roof of St. Peter burned and only its replacement was envisioned. The church is located on the south side of the town's principal plaza, and presents only a facade to the square. The facade bears relation to both Romanesque and Renaissance precedent. Its gable top rises sheer into a square bell tower topped by a cylindrical colonnade with a high, stilted dome. The cubic bell tower directly over the entry requires

a second strong wall parallel with the facade for support, the two walls framing the narthex. All this survived the fire and was incorporated into the new design.

The plan of the old church was a simple, three-aisled basilica with lower side aisles beyond a row of columns. H ad the intention for rebuilding remained solely the addition of a fireproof roof, there would have been little of architectural consequence. H owever, the intention came to be a rebuilding of everything beyond the narthex, and Dieste made the most of this opportunity.

Any new design was constrained by the rectangular site in the middle of the block. Dieste’s design has a deceptively simple plan (see fig. 56). It is a squat rectangle of a ratio of approx imately 4:5, suggesting no strong directionality To the south,

36

fig. 24 fig. 25

the nave continues into a sanctuary that is five sides of a slight- ly irregular octagon. The transverse section of the nave is also simple, yet this is the first step in achieving a remarkable spatial organization (fig. 24). The section is once again basilical; how- ever, no columns or piers—remarkably nothing—separates the nave from the long, broad side aisles. Since the side aisles togeher are wider than the nave and comparatively low, the central vessel, the nave, does achieve a strong horizontal direc- tionality The high side walls of the nave tilt inward such that the width of the nave at the roof lineis only about half that of the nave height, and the apparent height is intensified. The horizontal and vertical directionalities obtained with the high, indined side walls of the nave are all the more emphatic and resonate with symbolic significance by flowing seamlessly into the walls of the octagonal sanctuary. These walls rise well above the roof of the nave, sheltering a large concealed north window that brings direct sunlight streaming down the windowless south wall.

The roof of the naveis a strong complement to the powerful walls, with their continuity into the seemingly boundless height of the sanctuary. Like all other surfaces, the roof is wholly of brick, fashioned into long folded plates that form a low gable (fig. 25. The end of that low gable at the south provides a strong central focal point and sharp shadow line against the light in the sanctuary. The broad gable plates of the roof are stabilized laterally by horizontal plates that extend beyond the nave walls, acting as horizontal beams. To our sur- prise, there is a thin continuous band of light between the top of the nave wall and the roof, giving a soft illumination throughout the church without competing with the focal light over the altar. The horizontal band of clerestory windows does more than admit light. In this building so redolent of crafts- manship and sound tectonics, the seeming impossibility of that light source leaves the viewer with a conviction that here the material world itself has been overcome.

Due to the ingenious section and structure, the nave is, after all, a powerful directional force where form, tectonics, and light are in total congruence, subtly focusing attention on the most sacred part of the church. The spatial continuity of

fig. 26 fig. 27

the nave and side aisles is a secondary phenomenon but still vitally important to creating a sense of oneness between the congregants and the religious celebrants, in accord with Dieste's religious convictions.

A final surprise remains. Turning to leave, we see the third, and only other, source of light through an opening that is a tour de force in brick masonry (fig. 26). The old facade facing the square contains large lancet windows that gi ve generous light into the high narthex. In Diestes new inner wall of the narthex (the back wall of the nave), he suspends on tiny steel rods five concentric "rings" of brick in an irregular hexagon, creating a rose window that borrows light from the facade. Here too the beauty of the light and the improbability of the material phenomenon challenge our comprehension (fig. 27).

The folded plate construction used in Dieste’s church at Durazno is all but unique in the engineer's work; indeed, it is unique among the great buildings of the world. The side walls of the nave are over 100 feet in length. H ow can it be that there are no columns to support them? H ow can it be that there is a continuous source of light between the walls and roof of the nave? The answer is that the side walls of the nave and the folded planes of the roof are beams spanning the length of the church! They are supported on the reinforced inner wall of the narthex and a reinforced concrete portal frame at the sanctuary.

Placing structural members in the long direction of the space is itself counterintuitive, but if you would stretch your intuition, examine the transverse section of St. Peter. |n taking the apparently difficult path of spanning the church in the long direction, Dieste did not solve the problem with brute force. Observe the thinness of these wall/ beams and roof plates! The nave wall—a slightly inclined beam—is a compos- ite of brick and concrete, about 26 feet high and only about 10 inches thick, a ratio of 130. The principal roof plates, resting only 34 degrees off the horizontal, are even more amazing: little more than 3inches thick, they too span over 100 feet. The ratio of thickness to span is approximately 1400. The structural adequacy of these members is due to their form (the 26-foot height of the beam and the effective depth of the

fig. 28

folded roof plates), but the actual and conceptual thinness of the structural elements remains striking. While the impres- sive span of the nave walls and the virtual independence of the roof from the nave walls are visible to the viewer, it is true that the extraordinary thinness of wall and roof is not directly given to view. Yet the taut brick surfaces in this building convey a clear sense of an economy of means that is much more than a mere material matter (fig. 28). H ere again, Dieste has performed a "dance without effort or fatigue." He explains: The resistant virtues of the structures that we are searching for depend on their form. It is through their form that they are stable, not because of an awkward accumulation of matter. ... there is nothing more noble and elegant from an intellectual viewpoint than this resistance through form.12 Dieste's resistance through form was a matter of spanning space. The centrality of this evident fact entails an important and less obvious aspect of his work. Virtually all of his buildings have the simplest of rectangular plans--in the greatest of his buildings, the Church of Saint Peter, even an obtuse, unpromising rectangle. Where the walls are curving, ruled surfaces, they are bounded by a real or implied rectan- gle. With the exception of his house, it is not the plan that sets his buildings apart. Nor are their exteriors elaborated. It is the section that is the telling feature of Dieste's buildings

2 Dieste, “Architecture and Construction," 187 of this volume.

and, through the section, that his innovations of space, light, and structure are achieved. Despite the excellence and centrality of structure and construction, with Dieste, a build- ing offers little as an object and much as a space articulated for life.

Diestes innovations in structure also entailed quite exceptional innovations in construction: movable formwork, simple pre-stressing techniques, rapidity of construction, and the like. What is so evident in the Church of St. Peter is the exquisite brickwork. The overall impression is of such perfec- tion that one is convinced of the precision and economy of the thinking and performance that must lie behind such a work. This precision can be pursued down to details. At the junction of the nave, side aisle, and sanctuary, no two of these surfaces are at right angles to one another, ye the bonding here, as elsewhere, is perfect in its transitions. To achieve such perfection requires deeply informed planning on the part of the designer, but it will never be achieved without excellent collaborators during the design and construction process and, needless to say, skilled and devoted craftsmen.4

Early in his career, Dieste courageously disciplined him- self, his client, and his collaborators to achieve in the church at Atlantida a challenging work that went far beyond the initial program and established Dieste as an architectural force. The church at Durazno, with its intellectual as well as spiritual power, its refinement in both thought and execution, make it, | would argue, one of the major architectural achievements of the last half of the twentieth century. Dieste knew this and was willing to recognize that he had achieved architectural works, even if he was loath to title himself an architect.

Dieste was still more than an engineer and architect; he was a man with deep ethical concerns and broad intellectual interests. In his two churches he sought to unify the congrega- tion and the priest and liturgy for the well-being of people, especially those who labored or were dispossessed. At Atlántida, Dieste had fulfilled this ideal prior to the dictates handed down by the Second Vatican Council. He was a rali- gious man; you will find a crucifix on the wall of his study.

But his concerns were not framed by the Church or even by

38

religion more generally. His was a concern for humanity, expressed in both political and humanistic terms. H e wrote, "| think that we would reach a wide consensus if we proposed as a common aim the fulfillment and happiness of mankind. This is an aim that would certainly produce different principles in accordance with each individual's philosophy of life and his religion." After noting that “what we see around us is not acceptable," he continued, "The industrial revolution took place with such great injustice that the repercussions from the fierce indignation that its inequities produced in mankind are the reason for the destructive madness that has spread throughout the ۷۸۷۸۷۲ 16 Deeply concerned for the inequities suffered by the majority of the world population, and committed to the maintenance of well-being in countries like his own that were buffeted both by local constraints and the harms of interna- tional development activities, Dieste did not lose sight of the higher goals of humankind. In his essay "Technology and U nderdevelopment," he maintained: Efforts that are put to good use are efforts that help man to be happier, to be more himself. Efforts dedicated to science, art, health care, and efforts to make the earth, our country- side and cities, the true home of mankind, are efforts that are put to good use. If we understand development in this way, then it is both good and desirable.

13 In Remo Pedreschi and Gonzalo Larrambeberes essay in this volume, the authors make this point. See page 148.

14 Gonzalo Larrambebere, a longtime key member of the Dieste y Montañez office, confirms that the architect Alberto Castro Oyola and the engineer Antonio Raúl Romero Riveiro collaborated with Dieste both in the design and the direction of the construction of St. Peter. Gonzalo Larrambebere to Stanford Anderson, electronic communication, 28 May 2002.

Castro explains that both he and Romero were "immediate collabora- tors," working independently but from an initial idea that Dieste had, as usual, given in a small (now lost) sketch. H e states:

My initial participation was the architectural elaboration of the preliminary design based on Dieste's original idea. When this phase was completed, the engineer Romero worked

Embracing this general position, Dieste's own efforts were conducted as both science and art, and were directed not only to the home of mankind but to our edification.

Recognizing that calls for simplicity usually entail unjustified simplification and that those for economy address merely money and its movement, Dieste advanced a much larger cause: “The things that we build must have something that we could call a cosmic economy, that is, to be in accord with the profound order of the world. Only then can our work have the authority that so surprises us in the great works of the past.”18 While here Dieste refers to structures, we should see his notion of "cosmic economy” in terms of that "pro- found order of the world." The inexplicable harmonies of the Church of St. Peter are the fundamentals of his cosmic economy, but so too are his understandings of how his country should operate within a world of disparate opportunities, and how genuine goods must reach equitable distri bution.

Dieste's thought and work are undeniably metaphysical. Yet he rejects any teleology and his ambitions are always grounded:

It is not easy to have a clear image of the goal. On the other

hand, it is much easier to have a dear image of the founda-

tions and principles that will shape that goal. This is why the idea that "the ends justify the means” is a drastic mistake. We do not know what the end will be. We have an image of our

closely with Dieste to define the structure of the project.... Dieste directed the construction phase with Romero's support in structural issues and my support in architectural issues. At this point, the site superintendent Vittorio Vergalito was inte- grated in the team. Castro also emphasized that this had been an exceptional team effort but (as with other projects in the office) under the natural leadership of an exceptional man, Dieste. Alberto Castro to Stanford Anderson, electronic communication, 5 June 2002. Dieste's recognition of Castro's and Romeros construction appears in Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 1/4. Vergalito was also a trusted collaborator, having long superintended the construction of Dieste's works. 5 Dieste, "Architecture and Construction," 188 of this volume. 16 Ibid.

goals, but these will never be realized if in our actions we

betray the principles that will shape and form these goals. We

cannot postpone for the future city the beauty and dignity that we need so badly to endure the severities of life. We can- not postpone them as principles even though we might have to compromise in practice. When we have no other choice, we will have to compromise, but we should always continue to try to achieve the principles that will shape the goal, our

future 9 With this confrontation of principles and reality, it is tempting to recall Dieste's story of one of his professors, who, hearing the word “theoretical” used with disdain, retorted, “Theoretical, theoretical, the theoretical that fails in reality, fails because it isn't theoretical enough!”20 Dieste's thought, his search for "cosmic economy,” takes him readily to large and small issues in quite different domains, but there remains a selective and rational mind behind these ambitions.

Dieste's achievement has a strong moral and intellectual basis. It offers fundamental lessons. Within a period marked by naive modernist determinisms and conservative resistances, Dieste provided an unusual and strong counterexample. H e was an engineer working rationally from first principles, but he was also a pragmatic humanist who chose his course in accord with both limiting conditions and social ideals. He knew how to make his situation work for him and others

17 Eladio Dieste, “Technology and U nderdevelopment,” in Jimenez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 261

18 Dieste, “Architecture and Construction,” 186 of this volume.

19 Dieste, “Art, People, Technocracy,” 197 of this volume.

20 Eladio Dieste, quoted in Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 160.

without appeal to invented temporal imperatives. ۱۳ the end, he was the author of innovations that are undeniably modern, socially responsible, and of high environmental quality.

Successively stepping down from these flights, consider a word that may still alarm the fastidious: form. Dieste intro- duced his essay "Architecture and Construction" with these words:

[These] are reflections of an engineer who found in the pro-

cess of building warehouses, he was creating architecture,

even though that was not his object. H e also found that he had an awareness of form and in confronting this awareness, he discovered that it helped him to solve problems that were strictly structural.21 Form is antecedent to Dieste's structural discoveries. | do not think he is referring to such knowledge as the structural efficiency of catenary curves; this is too well known in his dis- cipline and too intimately related to structure to elucidate this passage. On the other hand, Dieste criticized the arbitrariness of architectural formalism, so his "awareness of form," though apparently susceptible to abstract exploration, is certainly part of a discipline. We are surely inserted once again in Dieste's "cosmic economy” but how can we understand this in a more concrete way?

A clue to answering this question appears in Diestes comment, “If | had to synthesize what has driven our search, | would say that it is the perennial value of the surface itself."22 "Surface" at first seems a dangerous word: "surface treat- ment," "surface coating," and the like suggest superficiality. We do not want to remain at the surface of a matter when it can be probed profoundly. Surely Dieste found something profound in the "perennial value of the surface,” and it is here that he recognized a realm of formal exploration that could in turn solve structural problems.

Dieste rejected reliance on rectilinear frame systems.23 He also resisted structural solutions that relied on two- dimensional curved forms such as arches and ribs.24 Such approaches invited solutions based on additional material rather than on structural efficiency. To the contrary, Dieste's

40

principal structural innovations relied on the efficacy of sur- faces with particular formal properties. The simple curve of the self-supporti ng vaults allowed them to perform as beams. The s-shape of each band of Gaussian vaults gave it the stiffness to span great distances. Of course, these vaults are of material and have thickness, but their shape is still more fundamental to their capacity. Dieste carefully detailed his buildings to facilitate the viewer's recognition of the literal and affecti ve power of form. Simply examine again how the can- tilever of a self-carrying vault terminates: so thin relative to the span that we think of line and surface rather than of mass.

The two vault systems that recur in Diestes work deserve acclaim within his "awareness of form,” but he had internalized these solutions so fully that he must have been thinking of still other formal explorations that helped him solve structural problems. | return to the planar beam and the folded roof plates of the Church of St. Peer. Planar forms can now be explored, but in assemblies where two or more planes work integrally to perform far beyond what they could achieve separately. The thickness of the walls and roofs is so slight relative to their extent that, again, we are inclined to think of them as surfaces. That reading is further motivated by the careful bonding and grouting of the bricks, turning the mate- riality of brick into elegant surfaces made evanescent by the effects of natural light.

21 Dieste “Architecture and Construction,” 182 of this volume.

22 Eladio Dieste, quoted in Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 218.

23 Dieste, “Architecture and Construction,” 182 of this volume.

24 Eladio Dieste, in Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 218.

25 Alberto Petrina, "From the South,” in Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 18.

Light, so effective in Dieste's most utilitarian buildings, is transcendent in St. Peter. The Argentinean architect Alberto Petrina gave a compelling appreciation of Dieste's use of light in the Church of Christ the Worker in Atlántida and, | would say most appropriately, of St. Peter:

In these churches light is an irreplaceable ingredient without

which the buildings would fall as if the structure had given

way. Light is pulled toward the chosen points as if by a mag- net; it is kneaded and mixed with the materials until it is part of them, it is exalted and transfigured. Light announces the

Divine Presence, or at least simulates perfectly that

presence.25 Ultimately, it is by the play of light on surfaces of material and structure, as well as by resisting through form, that Dieste achieves "a lightness, a mysterious ease, a concise simplicity, something like dance without effort or fatigue.”

CHURCH OF CHRIST THE WORKER

Atlántida, 1958-60

42

it HÀ | EE |

Remarkable but true, this church is Eladio Dieste's first architectural work, evolving from an initial contract for a simple vault in 1952. It is located in a formless village populated by agricultural and manual laborers.

At floor level, the plan of the church is a simple rectangle, from which undulating walls rise to the maximum amplitude of their arcs. These thin but self-stabilizing walls carry continuous double-curvature vaults with ti e-rods concealed in the almost-level troughs that are anchored in the brick edge- beams projected beyond the walls. These complex forms achieve a stunning simplicity as the walls and roof meet in a level plane.

Dieste wrote of his desire to unite the congregants with the officiants in a single space, which the nave of this church provides. The space also presents a spiritual itinerary for the rite of baptism, symbolizing acceptance into the family of the church: parallel to the main entrance, a projected, tunnel-like entry descends to the circular baptistery, from which another passage ascends to join the congregation in the unified space. The realm of the altar is demarcated through a slight change of level and careful use of light.

Light is a compelling force on the interior of the church. The accent at the altar and the suffused light throughout the nave emanate from obscured origins: shielded light sources at the choir above the entry; multi ple small windows cut into the curves of the brick wall that orient toward the altar; and a small crown of skylights let into the vaults above the altar. Revealing of the structure is the peri meter of light, which separates the structurally complete nave walls and roof from the freestanding entrance wall.

fig. 29: View of the north-facing entrance facade fig. 30: Raking view of the west wall

س ہے

گا ا a‏

La س‫ سے ہے‎ TR RET

T ——m—M © -= ہس‎

1 a

z = m ےکی‎ ilaga m ہا‎ c = r

E ————— وس‎ m ll 72 T Bin سے‎ L i . 1

X‏ و سنا

-— 1

TOTT

|

> fI ii

l U nderground baptistery II Confessionals

Il! Nave

IV Presbytery or sanctuary

“FU EELS

EOS V Chapel of the Virgin [ i y VI Sacristy LN p VII Antesacristy

fig. 31 Ast. VIII Campanile

fig. 3E Plan of the church. The church is "oriented" to the south.

fig. 32: Vittorio Vergalito, master mason with Dieste y Montañez. The walls of the church are ruled surfaces, the bricklaying controlled with straight lines established within the construction framework.

fig. 33: Sinusoidal walls and roof, before end walls were added

fig. 34: a) Longitudinal section. The continuous double-curvature vaults are perforated to admit light over the sanctuary. b) Transverse section, which to a technical eye reads as the moment diagram of the structure

overleaf fig. 35: East wall. The curvature of the walls renders the windows invisible as one enters the church.

fig. 32

44

pp

ETT

DEAL di S

= (o

"amm. RTP ZUR EXER ==

fig. 34

45

' Pe. | A DE SPEED - ٦ Se E ¿ee €: - ۱ = - " . LIZA Si ہے‎ en ad, rahe i a : سے‎ 2 Pin mS ^a x lr T — a b= á ps ۱ A Garp re ¡PA Se Bab i! Naty 5 ; i

«i mca EE agg. =

eee boe, — reel

A ہے‎ re — — -=

AZ — a کے یی کی‎

Dmm omm A m.

i 7 TEE C

= * Pan aat ار‎ “cen

p^

fig. 36

fig. 38

fig. 36: Axial view of the interior, from the entrance

fig. 37: Independent entrance. A passageway descends from here to the baptistery and continues into the church, a symbolic entrance to Christian faith.

fig. 38: Axial view toward the entrance, showing the light sources

49

fig. 39: View along the east wall toward the choir stair

fig. 40: View along the west wall revealing the independence of the end wall from the structure of the church

fig. 4E Diagonal view, illustrating how the sinusoidal walls and roof meet in a horizontal curved line

fig. 42: Chapel of the Virgin with a devotional window, a perspectivally exaggerated box that penetrates the wall. At the near, non- structural brickwork

fig. 39

o +

Oo

=

71 ا ا1

fig. 42

e t Oo

E

51

1 € 9

" fig. 43: Lateral view in the church

a fig. 44: Stair and choir railings li "d fig. 45: Canted brick grille with alabaster windows, which controls the

LEER A a’. a

strong north light from the entrance wall

"۲۱۷ +09۰۰۶

۳31111۱۲۷۲۱ ۸۵۵۵7

aT!

Ee 1

oa qa de a A

LI

i j mji e add s uf d a

iri cei

fig. 46: Campanile interior, illustrating prefabricated, cantilevered brick steps

fig. 47: West of the church, a campanile of penetrated brick

fig. 48: Late-afternoon sun, creating strong contrasts through the campanile on the form of the church

fig. 46

i TT į ‘

0 ۱ UNEN d =m j ML n 1 1 "

i j + A o ا‎ + :

—— a | —— a o! mn , a ^ | ; y | à; ] 2 " TUAE ۳۳ Ñ pet 0 ratih [n xn: €

٦

e wem جوا‎ w — am — uu mus

CAES

E LA

Eer و‎ » m. e 2-1

a.‏ او s‏ و

CHURCH OF OUR LADY OF A large new church, projected in 1961, was to envelop the existing church

LO U RDE 5 before its planned destruction. The new parish house and a fragment of the high walls of the sanctuary were built before economic conditions and the death of the supportive Father Freire halted the work. This towering construc- tion is a double brick wall with internal stairs, which eliminated the need for scaffolding during its construction. Drawings show a clerestory window of simple geometric pattern giving light from the tower onto the chancel. This was not a definitive design; there are also photographs of a model that showed an alternative of three, lightly scaled cruciform windows. The nave walls of the Malvín church were to have been of a greater height than those at Atlántida, and their ruled surfaces were to begin and end in undulating lines.

Malvin, Montevideo, 1965-68

Collaborator: Architect Alberto Castro

L ! j 5 t j à E à $ s 8

J

4 * ee ————‏ ` ` کڈ اد `

f M

is E

n F |

o.‏ ہے

pane سم سے سے سے سے ساس ص تع سد سے خی ت ےکا‎ A en re et

ME

rying , Wi

self-car

its perforated,

o * 3 S 5 P g S = A a z 2 t=

tion of the sanctuary of the church

| of the perforated vaults of the parish house

i ۱ | s 5 | = 3 | ? کے‎ | £ E E | BS Y 2 5S 2528 و و یہ‎ S = i = S5. o 5 20:983 | ES. 83 | S£2a 3063 R 2 8 E8 o o o a o = E E E E

fig. 53

CHURCH OF SAN JUAN DE ÁVILA

Alcalá de Henares, Madrid, Spain, 1996ff.

Dieste's late collaborative works built near Madrid include this church, designed in 1993 and based on the plans for the unfinished church in Malvín. The large rose window and the large cross as the clerestory window are not wholly satisfactory resolutions of what had remained uncertain in the original design nearly thirty years earlier.

Clemente and others also collaborated on additional churches in the same area of Madrid based on Dieste's designs. The Church of the Sagrada Familia in Torrejon de Ardoz and the Nuestra Madre del Rosario in Mejorada del Campo are close emulations of the churches in Atlántida and Durazno, respecti vely. Three more churches have since been built in the Diocese of Alcalá using Dieste's techniques.

Collaborators: Architects Carlos Clementeand Juan deDiosdelaHoz

fig. 53: View of the Spanish church based on the Malvín church design fig. 54: View up in the light tower above the sanctuary and to the first vaults of the nave

E 34 > | - + 1 4 dd ME کے‎ HÁT deed ntn LI: 1 RE I LS SS bà. F

al i — ex. mmt. 4 re

=

...000

m a.

fig. 54

LL di E E A ES / i | GA J ¿e Wheel

| f 1 p ر — - سے‎ A i EX. E

"E.

= A, _-

E

fig. 55

CHURCH OF SAINT PETER [SAN PEDRO]

Durazno, 1969-71

60

ERU ., ed

The neo-Romanesque facade, narthex, and outer walls of the Church of St. Peter (San Pedro) survived a fire that otherwise demolished the building. Dieste transcended the initial call for a new roof by conceiving a church with unique space and light that deserves to be counted among the best modern churches in the world. The structural technology of St. Peer is all but unique in Dieste's work.

It is built entirely of very thin folded plates that span over 100 feet between the narthex and sanctuary walls, allowing a completely open plan contrasting with a basilical cross section that would usually be divided by rows of columns. The plates that form the nave walls and side aisle roofs, and those that form the high roof, are joined only by small steel, recessed posts. A narrow band of light between these plates simultaneously reveals this remarkable structural feat and more importantly provides an evocative, even light throughout the nave. This controlled light creates the ambience against which the drama of the sanctuary light is played. The sanctuary walls rise high to open a large clerestory window, out of sight above the plates of the nave roof. Opening from the direction of the sun, the high window floods the sanctuary with light that varies in intensity, direction, and pattern, a moving complement to the still environment of

the nave. On the wall above the entrance, the ethereal brick of the rose window filters light from the narthex and original facade.

Collaborators: Architect Alberto Castro and Engineer Raúl Romero

fig. 55: Facade and narthex/ tower of St. Peter, located on the south side of the main square of Durazno

fig. 56: Plan of the church, with the existing facade and narthex only outlined

fig. 57: Axial view from the entrance, illustrating the continuous light source between wall and roof, and the dramatic lighting of the sanctuary from the high clerestory window

Existing narthex

Nave

Presbytery or sanctuary Confessionals

Bb WN بر‎

fig. 56

fig. 57

fig. 58

fig. 59

62

fig. 60

TECHO DE NAVE CENTRAL

ALZADO VIGA PARED

ننس | کوعھ/ ia‏

PRINCIPAL Hals FORT TEAL. EKIN ع‎ £L ttn ol Lain وجار‎ /32

fig. 58: Angled view showing the continuity of space from the side aisles and the fine brickwork from the spanning wall/ beam into the support of the sanctuary walls

fig. 59: An axonometric section, revealing the extreme thinness of the folded plates, their long span, and the open plan of the church

fig. 60:Partial transverse section.

fig. 61 (top) Reinforcing pattern for the roof, (bottom) reinforcing for the nave walls

fig. 62: View of the sanctuary, with crucifix by Claudio Silvera Silva, originally from Durazno

fig. 62

fig. 63 fig. 64

fig. 63: View of the narthex, with the old facade to the left and the new wall with rose window to the right

fig. 64: Looking back through the nave, with its continuous surfaces of 5

simple brickwork, to the rose window above the entrance ۱ fig. 65: Longitudinal section, showing the clarity and simplicity of the

church that nevertheless contains so many effective nuances fig. 66:The seemingly free-floating brick of the rose window

— EET E

64

GUASTAVINO, DIESTE, AND THE TWO REVOLUTIONS IN MASONRY VAULTING Edward Allen

Two successive revolutions transformed masonry vaulting from the thick, handcrafted roofs of the ancients, shaped and proporti oned by intuition, to the steel-rei nforced, mathemati- cally designed, thin brick shells of the late twentieth century. Thefirst revolution began in the late nineteenth century in Catalonia, where Rafael Guastavino applied the then-new discipline of graphic statics to traditional Catalan vaulting to produce the first scientifically engineered masonry structures. The second was wrought in the last half of the twentieth century by Eladio Dieste who, with the numerical theory of reinforced concrete shells as his point of departure, designed and built clay masonry roofs in daring new forms that spanned unprecedented distances. This discussion will focus on Guastavinos work and its relationship to that of other architects and engineers of his time. It will conclude by con- trasting Guastavinos innovations with those of Eladio Dieste.

The Application of Graphic Statics to the Development of Masonry Vaults

Historically, masonry vaulting developed along three paths: the European, the Middle Eastern, and the Catalan (fig. 67). The European path induded Roman, Romanesque, Gothic, and Renaissance vaulting. The design of European vaults was generally based on the geometry of the circle, and the vaults were erected over temporary centering or formwork. Working in this fashion resulted in relatively thick vaults, with the long dimensions of their stones or bricks lying along radial lines. The inclined thrusts of the vaults are resisted by either engaged or flying buttresses.

The second path of development took place in the Middle East, where both barrel vaults and domes were erected without the use of centering. For vaults, centering was elimi- nated by inclining the courses of bricks against an end wall and for domes, by building in a spiral pattern. The resulting vault shapes often tended toward a parabolic geometry rather

66

fig. 67: The three types of traditional masonry vaults: European, Middle Eastern, and Catalan

than a circular one, probably because it was easier for the mason, when working without centering, to keep bricks in place in a partially completed vault if they were laid along a parabolic line Middle Eastern vaults are about as thick as European ones. Their thrusts are resisted by thick walls or engaged buttresses.

Thethird path of traditional masonry vault develop- ment—the Catalan vaulting techni que— emerged in the region around Barcelona and is distinctly different from the other two. It utilizes multiple, overlapping laminations of thin tiles whose long dimensions lie in the curving surface of the vault. Catalan vaults are much thinner and lighter in weight than either European or Middle Eastern vaults. They are often also much shallower, sometimes rising as little as 10 percent of the span. They are extremely strong due to the staggering of joints between one tile lamination and the next. They are sometimes called timbrel vaults in reference to their extreme thinness, which is likened to that of the head of a timbrel, a small hand- drum or tambourine.

Vault forms commonly constructed in Catalonia included domes, barrel vaults, pillow-shaped vaults, and helical stairs. Even "flat vaults," planar laminated tile slabs, were often built to span very short distances, usually not more than three feet or so. All the Catalan vault forms were erected without centering by using ingenious construction procedures.! These procedures are made possible by joining the tiles edge to edge in the first layer with plaster of Paris (pure gypsum), which is very fast-setting and highly adhesive. Because this materi al weakens when wetted, it is unsuitable for use as the primary mortar in a vault. Subsequent layers of tile are bonded to each other and to the first layer with portland cement mortar, which IS water resistant and much stronger than plaster of Paris.

Until late in the nineteenth century, masonry vaulting was shaped and proportioned by guesswork or rules of thumb. As a consequence, vaults based on the European or Middle Eastern precedents tended to be not only thick but also heaw and expensive. Catalan vaults were much thinner but were also designed by wholly intuitive methods. A correct under- standing of vault shapes and forces had been formulated as

fig. 67

early as the end of the seventeenth century, as demonstrated in a treatise by Giovanni Poleni (1683-1761), published in 1748, on finding the ideal shape for a dome It was not until Karl Culmann (1821-1881) transformed Poleni's hypothesis into a simple and powerful working method, however, that it became easy to find correct shapes and forces for masonry arches and vaults. Culmann's Die graphische Statik, published in 1866 by the Swiss Federal Technical University (ETH) in Zurich,

was the first comprehensive presentation of graphic statics, a method of structural design that employs scaled drawings rather than numerical operations.? Graphic statics made it possible to determine the ideal form for a masonry vault and the forces within the vault quickly and simultaneously.

The use of graphic statics to find the form and forces for a vaulted roof that spans 280 feet over an athletic arena is illustrated in figures 68-71 The given conditions are that the vault must spring from abutments X and Z and it must pass through point Y on its vertical centerline. In order for a vault to be stable under a uniform gravity load, each segment of it must be in static equilibrium. This requires that three forces—the pull of gravity on the segment and the two indined compressi ve forces exerted on it by the segments on either side— must balance one another. It is a fundamental axiom of physics that when the vectors of these three forces, connected tip to tail, form a dosed triangle, this equilibrium is achieved.

The goal of this design procedure is to find a funicular shape for the vault. The word "funicular" stems from the Latin funiculus, meaning "string," and a funicular shape for a vault that is subjected to a given pattern of loads is the inversion of the shape that is assumed by a flexible string or cable when it is subjected to the same pattern of loads. For a single, concen- trated load, a funicular shape for a cable will resemble the letter v; thefunicular shape for a vault will resemble an inverted v. For aload uniformly distributed over the horizontal projection of a vault, a funicular shape will be a parabola; for a vault that carries its own weight only, a funicular shape is a catenary, which is very close in shape to a parabola (although much more complex to represent mathematically). The advan- tage of a funicular shape is that the vault experiences only

pure compression, and not bending, when it is subjected to the load for which it was designed. This allows it to be built with a minimum of material. More often than not, it also produces a shape that we perceive as being elegant.

In this illustrative example, the total vertical load on a one-foot strip of vault has been esti mated to be 21,000 pounds. At the top of figure 68, this load is divided into a con- venient number of segments: seven of 3000 pounds each in this case. Each segment is then represented just below on the drawing by a concentrated force of the same magnitude that is centered on the segment. The lines of action of these forces are extended downward over a section view of the arena. The magnitudes and directions of these forces are represented on a vertical load line to the right, where they are drawn ti p-to-tail to a convenient scale of pounds to inches. The overall length of the load line at this scale is equal to the total load on the entire span of the one-foot strip of vault.

Because the vault is uniformly loaded in horizontal projection, we know that the funicular shape is a parabola. A parabola has the useful property that lines that are tangent to its ends will intersect at a point on its vertical centerline. This point lies at a distance above the parabola's closing string (baseline) that is exactly twice the parabola's altitude. In figure 68, the baseline or dosing string of the parabola is drawn between its endpoints, X and Z. The altitude of point Y,

1 Anumber of these procedures are illustrated in Timothy P. Becker and Kent Anderson's essay on pages 202-07 of this volume.

2 Giovanni Poleni, M emorie | storiche della Gran Cupola de Tempio Vaticano (Padua, 1/48), quoted in Hans Straub, A H ¡story of Civil Engineering (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1964), 140-42.

3 Karl Culmann, Die graphische Statik (Zurich: ETH, 1866).

67

VU

at a depo... pa zs zero exe Zee

aec oe F G H‏ ےہ 7 i o‏ و .سے ےچ

An example of the use of graphic statics to find the form and forces for a vaulted roof. Each arrow is a vector. The direction of the arrow indicates the direction of the force, and the length of the arrow is proportional to the magnitude of the force.

fig. 68: Setting up the graphical solution

fig. 69:The first segments of the vault, oa and ob, are constructed

fig. 70: Another segment of the vault, oc, is added

fig. 7E The finished solution

through which the parabola must pass, is measured as dis- tance s. Another vertical distance of s is laid off above Y, and lines are drawn to connect this point to X and Z. These two lines are tangents to the ends of the parabolic vault. They are therefore the directions of the forces that the foundation abutments must exert upon the vault.

To the right in figure 68, alineis drawn through point a at the top of the load line, parallel to the left-hand tangent line, and another through the other end of the load line, h, parallel to the right-hand tangent. These intersect at a point labeled o.

Theresulting triangular diagram is an equilibrium trian- gle for the vault strip as a whole The load line represents the total load on the strip of vault, and line segments oa and oh represent the forces exerted on the ends of the strip by the abut- ments. We can measure the lengths of oa and oh on this diagram at the given scale to determine the magnitudes of the forces that they represent. This diagram is also the first stage in the con- struction of what is called the force polygon, a scaled diagram that will eventually indude line segments that are proportional in length to the internal forces in every part of the vault.

In figure 69, line ob is drawn on the force polygon to complete an equilibrium triangle for the point on the vault under the leftmost 3,000-pound load. Then segment ob is drawn parallel to this line on the section view to the left, start- ing from the point where line oa intersects the line of action of the leftmost load. The heaw lines oa and ob on the section are both tangent to the curve of the vault. By scaling the lengths of segments oa and ob on the force polygon to the right, we determine the magnitudes of the forces in these two regions of the Lfoot strip of vault.

In figure 70, these same steps are followed for the vault's next point of loading. | n the equilibrium triangle on the force polygon to the right, which is drawn with heavy lines, the first and second equilibrium triangles share a com- mon force, ob. Segment oc is scaled to determine the force in the vault segment that has just been drawn.

This process is repeated until the force polygon and section drawing are complete (fig. 7). The actual curve of the

fig. 72: Composite drawing of a selection of masonry domes constructed in North America by Rafael Guastavino

fig. 73: Construction drawing for the dome of St. Paul's Chapel, Columbia University, by Rafael Guastavino's consulting structural engineer, Nelson Goodyear. The several fan-shaped diagrams were used to find an optimum form for the dome and to determine the forces within it.

0 KUND " LOT H HAENEN “SOME DOMES CONSTRUCTED BY | E

QUAS SAVING و‎

vault will be a smooth curve that passes through X and Z and is tangent to the midpoints of the other plotted segments. Without using numerical mathematics, we have found a funic- ular shape for this vault, and we have determined the forces in it with a maximum error of about 1 percent.

The payoff for constructing a vault in a funicular shape rather than as a segment of a circle is that it can be built with great economy of materials. The vault that was designed in figures 68-71, for example, would, in theory, if constructed of masonry with an allowable stress of 600 psi, span the 280 feet with a thickness of only 2.7 inches, which is about Y 1200 of its span.

This technique for designing a funicular vault is remarkably fast and effective: it simultaneously finds a funicu- lar form for the vault and the magnitudes of the forces in its various segments. Of the various dosely related techniques that make up the repertoire of graphic statics, this is typical. They were adopted by engineers and architects around the world as soon as they were introduced.

The First Revolution: Rafael Guastavino and Graphic Statics Beginning in the late 1860s, Rafael Guastavino (1842-1908) designed and constructed a number of large industrial build- ings in Barcelona in which he used traditional Catalan lami- nated tile vaulting for the floor and roof structures. In 1881he left Barcelona and emigrated to New York, where he estab- lished a company that over the ensuing seven decades created well over one thousand vaulted structures across North America. Many of these were incorporated into buildings by such well-known architects as McKim, Mead, and White, Ralph Adams Cram, Bertram Goodhue, Warren and Wetmore, Ernest Flagg, Cass Gilbert, and Carrére and Hastings. In Manhattan, Guastavino constructed vaults in more than three hundred buildings, induding Grant's Tomb (1890), the Cathedral of St. John the Divine (1908-19), Grand Central Station (1909-13), the Ellis Island Immigrant Hall (1917), the Federal Reserve Bank (1923-24), and Riverside Church (1930), to name only a few prominent examples. The Boston Public Library (1887-98) and several Boston-area churches also fea-

ture Guastavino vaulting, as well as the state capitol buildings of Minnesota (1895-1903) and Nebraska (1920-32). Guastavino’s work can be found in forty-one U.S. states, five Canadian provinces, and nine other countries (fig. 72).5

Before Guastavi no began his career, masonry vaults and domes— whether European, Middle Eastern, or Catalan— were shaped and proportioned by intuition and tradition and tended to be heavy and wasteful of material. By applying graphic statics to Catalan laminated tile vaulting techniques, Guastavino was able to design and build thin, sleek, economi- Cal, scientifically engineered masonry shells (fig. 73. Graphic statics permitted Guastavino to give a funicular shape to each of his vaults. This minimized bending stresses while produc- ing shapes that were generally parabolic or catenary in section rather than circular. Graphic statics also permitted the deter- mination of the minimum permissible thickness for each structure, allowing Guastavino to use only as much material as was absolutely required to support the load with a suitable factor of safety. H e was thus able to build vaults that were thin, graceful, and so durable that most survive in excellent condition today. They are typically only 3inches thick and weigh a fraction of what traditional vaults weigh. Because they were made of fired clay tiles, they are also highly resistant to fire. Furthermore, they were often lower in initial cost than any other spanning method, and given their obvious durability

4 |n practice, this dimension would have to be increased somewhat to provide sufficient protective embedment for rei nforcing bars, and the vault would have to be stiffened with ribs, folds, or corrugations to help it resist wind loads and unbalanced snow loads.

5 For a comprehensive study of Guastavinos life and work, see George R. Collins, "The Transfer of Thin Masonry Vaulting from Spain to America," Journal of the Society of Architectural H istorians 27, no. 3 (October 1968): 176-201

69

fig. 74: A Guastavino Company detail sheet for a typical Renaissance dome. The total thickness of the structural tiles is 5 to 6 inches, depending on span and load.

fig. 75: Rafael Guastavino (right), inspecting laminated tile arches that will support floor vaults at the Boston Public Library

fig. 76: Laminated tile domes, built without using formwork and support- ed by the tile arches, beneath the front stairs of the Boston Public Library

fig. 77: Semicircular vault in the Boston Public Library. Because a semicircle is not an ideal shape for a vault, stiffening ribs and transverse

1

ZA A.

stiffening walls were necessary to assure the stability of the vault. fig. 78: Guastavino tile vaults in the Boston Public Library, finished with decorative tiles and exposed to view

ra)

fig. 76 | | MEME fig. 78

70

fig. 79: Graphical computation for finding the form of the retaining wall vaults in the Parc Güell, Barcelona. This is one of the few drawings by Antoni Gaudí to survive the Spanish Civil War.

(in a number of recent restorations of Guastavino buildings, few tiles have needed replacement), their life-cycle cost has proved to be extremely low (fig. 74).

The Catalan technique was indispensable to Guastavino because it enabled him to build as thin a vault as his graphical calculations indicated. It also permitted him to build without the expense and delay of having to erect and remove temporary formwork, except for simple forms needed to support planar arches during construction. Guastavino's workers assembled his vaults in midair, starting from the perimeter and working toward the center (figs. 75-8). Wires, strings, and templates were used as guides to produce accu- rate vault shapes. Guastavino's crews avoided the need for scaffolding by laying tiles "overhand"—standing on the work they had already put in place to gain access to the working edge of the vault. Their standard of workmanship was very high, as can be observed in any of the perfectly formed, highly finished vaults that they constructed.6

After Guastavino: Other U sers of Graphic Statics

Guestavinos factory for the Batllo Company in Barcelona, constructed between 1869 and 1875, was visited each year by students from the local architecture school, among them the young Antoni Gaudí (1852- 1926),7 who would soon embark on his lifelong search for a "natural" architecture. H aving learned graphic statics from his friend Joan Martorell shortly after graduation, Gaudí used the technique throughout his career to find "natural" (meaning funicular) shapes for the Catalan laminated tile vaults of his roof and floor structures, just as Guastavino did contemporaneously in the United States.8 But Gaudí went one step further, using graphic statics also to determine the directions of the thrusts that emerged from the bases of his vaults and to align the sup- porting columns along these lines of thrust. He was thus able to avoid constructing buttresses, which he considered unnat- ural. The inclined columns that result from this procedure are particularly prominent in his Parc Guell (1900-14), Guell Chapel (1898-1915), and Expiatory Temple of the Sagrada Familia (1884ff) (fig. 79).

fig. 79

It is widely known that Gaudi employed an elaborate hanging string model to find the structural form for his Güell Chapel. H owever, it is well documented that he, like Guastavino, did most of his structural design by means of graphic statics. H e said of the two methods, "The curves of the vaults of the Sagrada Familia were found graphically, and those of the Güell Chapel were arrived at experimentally, however, it turns out that both procedures produce the same result, and that the one is the child of the other."?

Gaudi was but one of a large group of gifted architects who worked in and around Barcelona in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, most or all of whom used graphic statics to design their vaulted masonry structures. Among the finest of the structures built by this group are the works of Luis Moya Blanco (1904-1990) and the more than thirty agricultural cooperative buildings by César Martinell Brunet (1888-1973), which adhered closely to the "natural" approach championed by Gaudi.

In using graphic statics, Gaudi and Guastavino placed themselves in the mainstream of the structural engineering practice of their time. Gustave Eiffel (1832-1923) employed as his assistant Maurice Koechlin (1856- 1946), who had been Karl Culmann's student at the ETH. Koechlin applied Culmann's graphic statics to find forms and forces for Eiffel’s structures. The form of the Eiffel Tower, a symmetrical

6 SeeJane Parks and Alan G. Neumann, The O ld World Builds the N ew: The Guastavino Company and the Technology of the Catalan Vault, 1885- 1962 (New York: Columbia University, 1996).

7 Collins, “The Transfer of Thin Tile Vaulting,” 191

8 Joan Bassegoda Nonell, A Guideto Gaudí (Barcelona: Edicions de Nou Art Thor, 1989), 8.

9 César Martinell Brunet, Conversaciones con Gaudí (Barcelona: Ediciones Punto Fijo, 1969), 39. Translation by the author. For further insights into Gaudí's structural design methods, see Santiago Rubió, Cálculo funicular del hormigón armado (Buenos Aires: Ediciones Gustavo Gili, 1952). Rubió's father was Gaudi’s structural engineer.

10 SeeLuis Moya Blanco, Bóvedas tabicadas (Madrid: Dirección General de Arquitectura, 1947), and César Martinell Brunet, Construcciones agrarias en Cataluña (Barcelona: La Gaya Ciencia, 1976).

71

fig. 80: Simple graphical construction, used by Gustave Eiffel to find the form of the Eiffel Tower. More complex graphical analyses were used to verify the design for every part of the tower.

fig. 81 Fan-shaped force polygons, used by Robert Maillart to find the pressure lines and internal forces in the arch of the Salgina Bridge for various loading conditions. The tapering arches of the bridge were shaped to contain these pressure lines.

fig. 82: Antoní Bonet, Berlingieri house, Punta Ballena, with vaults by Dieste, 1946-47

cantilevered truss that is funicular for its assumed wind load- ing pattern, was found through a simple graphical procedure (fig. 80). Employing this form permitted Eiffel to avoid includ- ing major diagonal braces in the bottom two panels of the tower, thus maintaining the open appearance essential to

the tower's aesthetic success." His Garabit and Douro River bridges are supported by trussed funicular arches whose boomerang shapes were determined graphically so as to con- tain the pressure lines for all the loading patterns exerted by moving trains.

Swiss engineer Robert Maillart (1872-1940) learned graphic statics from Culmann’s successor at the ETH, Wilhelm Ritter (1847- 1906). Maillart used the techniques to shape his concrete bridges along the paths of the forces that they con- duct and to find the forces in them (fig. 85.2 Like the iron and steel arches of Eiffel's bridges, the concrete arches of Maillart's boxarch bridges, such as the Salgina Bridge, are shaped to contain all possible pressure lines. In his deck-stiffened arch bridges, such as the Schwandbach Bridge, the shape of the daringly thin arch was based on a symmetrical loading condi- tion found by graphic statics. Asymmetrical loadings were accommodated by stiffening the deck so that it distributes the loads and restrains the arch from excessive deformations. The resulting forms continue to be admired to this day.

Eladio Dieste and the Second Revolution in Masonry Vaulting Eladio Dieste studied graphic statics at the Facultad de Ingeniería de Montevideo, an experience that contri buted to the formation of his structural intuition and made him con- scious of the economy and beauty that can result from align- ing the elements of a structure along lines of force. He also learned numerical methods for engineering calculations, including the theory and practice of designing concrete struc- tures with steel reinforcing, prior to his graduation in 1943 Brick masonry was the most economical mode of con- struction in Uruguay, and Dieste chose from the outset to build almost all of his works in this material. At the time, engineers such as Felix Candela (1910-97) and Eduardo Torroja (1899- 1961) were enjoying worldwide fame for their

72

BR ERA E

fig. 80

sleek shell structures made of reinforced concrete—the favored material of the modern movement. In choosing brick over concrete, Dieste swam against a strong current of fash- ion, virtually guaranteeing his own obscurity: "| discovered in brick," Dieste wrote, a material with unlimited possibilities, almost completely ignored by modern technology, and began to use it structural- ly....l am convinced that structural brick has the same great possibilities that reinforced concrete has... The fact that this technology leads to the predominance of varied surfaces tends to produce more magnificent, or we could say symphonic, spaces. This contrasts with the rather elemental spaces that contemporary architecture produced in its beginnings. 14 Dieste's first, tentati ve steps in this direction were taken just three years out of engineering school, in 1946, with the cylin- drical, reinforced brick roof vaults of the Berlingieri house. 5 His powers developed at such a pace thereafter that only a decade later, Dieste was able to design the doubly curved, post- tensioned brick shells and sinusoidal walls of the Church of Christ the Worker in Atlántida (designed 1955-57, constructed 1958-60), which is considered by many to be his greatest architectural achievement. Antoní Bonet (1913-1989), the architect of the Berlingieri house, proposed to Dieste that he should structure the house in Punta Ballena with vaults of thin tiles, built with-

ll For an example of Eiffel's use of graphic statics, see Gustave Eiffel, La Tour detrois cents metres (Paris: Imprimerie Mercier, 1900), 36.

12 David Billington, Robert M aillart's Bridges: The Art of Engineering (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1979), 7.

13 Antonio Dieste, note to the author, summer 2000.

14 Eladio Dieste, in Antonio Jiménez Torrecillas, ed., Eladio D ieste 1943-1996, trans. Michael Maloy and Harold David Kornegay (Seville: Consejeria de Obras Püblicas y Transportes, 1996), 27, 30.

15 For a detailed discussion on this project, see John Ochsendorf's essay on pages 96-97 of this volume.

16 Gonzalo Larrambebere, Dieste's longtime associate, communicated this insight to the author in a conversation that took place at Altzella, near Dresden, Germany, in June 1999. Larrambebere further stated that he did not know why Gausss name would be related in Diestes mind to cylindrical

B fe

fig. 81

out formwork in the Catalan tradition, much as Guastavino had done. Instead, Dieste chose to build with conventional bricks, using formwork for temporary support during construction (fig. 82). His work differed from that of Guastavino in other important ways, as well. Although Guastavino patented techniques for both reinforcing and post-tensioning, most of his roofs were constructed of unre- inforced masonry, whereas Dieste nearly always used steel reinforcing, often in combination with post-tensioning. Guastavinos structures were mostly shaped as traditional vaults and domes, whereas Dieste adopted and improved upon some of the new structural forms that had become popular in the twentieth century. Furthermore, Guastavino did his engineering with graphical methods, and Dieste with numerical methods, which were much better suited to the design of his cascaras autoportantes ("self-supporting shells"), which act in bending rather than pure compression.

Eladio Dieste's Structural Forms

Dieste's building structures fall into four general categories, none of which was feasible in Guastavinos time. His largest industrial roofs, which span up to 180 feet, are essentially shallow barrel vaults that act entirely in compression. For these he coined the name bóvedas gausas, which translates lit- erally as "Gaussian vaults"— apparently an admiring reference

vaults. Subsequently, Stanford Anderson called the author's attention to a passage from Mario Salvadori's W hy Buildings Stand U p: The Strength of Architecture (New York: W. W. Norton, 1980), in which Salvadori recog- nizes Gauss for the "discovery that all the infinitely varied curved surfaces we can ever find in nature or imagine belong to only three categories, which are domelike, cylinderlike, or saddlelike” (188). Domelike curvature is commonly referred to as “synclastic,” meaning that at every point on its surface, all curvatures are in the same direction. Saddlelike curvature is “anticlastic,” which indicates that at every point, curvatures along mutually perpendicular axes are in opposite directions. Dieste's Gaussian vaults are fundamentally cylindrical in shape. H owever, in order to remain stable under asymmetrical loading conditions such as drifting snow or strong winds, a cylindrical vault would have to be very thick. Dieste's response is to keep the vault thin and slice it into strips. The cross section of each strip

fig. 82

to Carl Friedrich Gauss (1777-1855), the great mathematician of Göttingen (fig. 833). Dieste's second building type, his cascaras autoportantes, is made up of cylindrical barrel shells (fig. 835). | n their curved direction, these act in compression, just like the bóvedas gausas, whereas in their longitudinal axes, they act as beams, deriving bending strength from their shape. The largest spans Dieste achieved with these structures were 43 feet between columns in the curved direction and 108 feet in the longitudinal direction, with longitudinal cantilevers as great as 54 feet. Of the third category, estructuras plegadas ("folded structures"), only two examples rank among his major works. One of these—the Church of St. Peter at Durazno (fig. 83c)—is noted proudly by the Dieste office in the list of their works as "technically the highest-ranking work built by our firm." |t is composed entirely of planar surfaces that join one another in the same way as the planes of a folded piece of cardboard, and it is from this folding that the struc- ture derives its strength and stiffness. The fourth category of building structures, superficies regladas ("ruled surfaces"), is represented by the walls of the Atlántida church; as well as its much later sequel, the Church of San Juan de Ávila, construct- ed in Alcalá de Henares, near Madrid, in 1996; and the shop- ping center in Montevideo (fig. 83d).18 The shapes of these walls were generated by straight line segments whose ends were translated along sinusoidal paths.

begins at its springings as a straight, horizontal line that soon morphs into an s-shape whose depth increases until it reaches a maximum at the crown of the vault. ۱۳ the higher portion of each strip, curvature of the masonry surfaces is domelike or synclastic. ۱۳ the lower portion, it is saddlelike or anticlastic. The net effect is that the strip is stiffened by two different kinds of curvature at any point on its span. Additionally, of course, this shape provides daylight and sheds water to a built-in gutter. Structurally and functionally, it is a clever solution that also looks very elegant and graceful. 17 Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 293.

18 Dieste never used the saddle-shaped hyperbolic paraboloid, the ruled surface that made Felix Candela famous, even though from a technical standpoint he could have done so. Perhaps he disliked its appearance, but it seems more likely that he simply did not find it as useful as other struc- tural forms for the work at hand.

73

74

fig. 83: The four primary structural types built by Eladio Dieste: a) bovedias pusas (Gaussian vaults); b) cascares autoportantes (self-supporting shells); c) eiruduras plegadas (folded structures); and d) superfides regladas (ruled surfaces)

y Hy Lud D Mm یی‎ Voy eee

Dieste was not the only designer to work in reinforced masonry during the years immediately following World War ll. |. Sanchez del Rio de Pisón designed and constructed many innovative reinforced clay tile structures in Spain. Torroja, a structural engineer like Sanchez and Dieste, built several brick-vaulted churches and water towers.29 There were others as well who built with reinforced brickwork, but two things set Dieste's work above the rest. One is his unmatched use of masonry in structures subject to bending, such as cantilevered barrel shells, tanks under hydrostatic pressure, and folded plates. The other is the power and poetry of his masonry architecture. Dieste's mind seemed to move effortlessly from the mathematical to the ethereal, from the mechanical to the philosophical. H e saw all of his efforts as a seamless whole, never separating the technical concerns from the artistic. Even in his churches, structure, form, and space are one: there are no non-loadbearing elements added (or needed) to sculpt the interior space. One need only compare his Atlantida and Durazno churches to any of the masonry churches designed by the far more famous Torroja to understand that Dieste was an authentic genius, both as an engineer and as an architect.?!

In Rafael Guastavinos time, the discipline of graphic statics was the most expedient means of finding a theoretically correct form for a vault and for finding the forces within it. By the time Eladio Dieste began his work, graphic statics was

19 Seel. Sanchez del Rio de Pisón, Estructuras “laminares cerámicas” (Madrid: Río-Cerámica, S.A., 1959).

20 Eduardo Torroja, The Structures of Eduardo Torroja (New York: F. W. Dodge, 1958), 168-87.

21 Foran insightful comparison of Diestes and Torrojas masonry churches, see Ochsendorf's essay on pages 97-100 of this volume.

falling gradually into disuse, in part because it was ill-adapted to the new forms of shells that were then being built and because numerical methods of analysis were becoming the norm. But the works of the great engineers and architects of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries—including those of Guastavino, Eiffel, Gaudí, and Maillart— were all structures that worked in pure compression and were all designed through graphic statics. These provided the founda- tion of theory and experience upon which Dieste's generation of designers would develop their unprecedented structures.

The author wishes to thank Janet Parks and Jim Epstein of the Guastavino Archive, Avery Architectural Library, Columbia University, Professor Joan Bassegoda i Nonell of the Gaudí Archive, Barcelona; Christiane Crasemann Collins; Aaron Schmidt of the Print Department, Boston Public Library; Professor Stanford Anderson of MIT; all the members of the Dieste y Montañez office in Montevideo, Uruguay; Professor María E. Yuguero; Amanda Miller; Timothy Becker; and Wadaw Zalewski.

fig. 84

TEM FACTORY

M ontevideo, 1960-62

76

es "9

رسس =

The TEM factory provides a classic example of one of Dieste's two basic vault types: the Gaussian, or double-curvature, vault. As early as 1955, Dieste built discontinuous vaults that provide clerestory lighting between the vaults, but they were heavy and not of a very great span. At 140 feet, the TEM factory became the first of Dieste's Gaussian structures with a truly breathtaking span. In the cross section of such a construction, the arc of the vault is a catenary and thus, under dead load, generates only compressive forces. At longer spans, however, and particularly where the rise of the vault is shallow, the vault becomes subject to buckling and collapse. In the longitudinal section of the building, at the crown of the vaults, Dieste developed an S-shaped undulation that increased the moment of inertia with little increase in weight. The vault being level at its springing also simplifies support conditions and drainage.

In 1975, the factory suffered a catastrophic fire, with gas explosions and extremely intense heat. Two of the vaults collapsed and pulled down a large piece of athird. Dieste spoke of this with pride, as the partially destroyed vault retained its integrity and was easily repaired.

Architects: Studio Clerk and Guerra

fig. 85

fig. 84: Interior view showing windows between vaults and lining the side and end walls of the building fig. 85: Rooftop view of discontinuous double-curvature vaults

77

fig. 86

CEASA PRODUCE MARKET

Porto Alegre, Brazil, 1969-72

78

This vast project, built for the Centro de Abastecimiento, S.A., includes a cen- tral 150- by 900-foot “Growers' Pavilion” of long-span double-curvature vaults with side wings serving as broad edge beams to resist the lateral thrust. The nearby "Traders Pavilions” employ a large array of simple self-carrying vaults, and a vehicular entrance portico is constructed with double-cantilever self- carrying vaults.

Self-carrying vaults are catenaries in their transverse section. As single curvature-vaults, the transverse spans are small. Adjoining vaults create valleys that jointly resolve lateral thrusts. Dieste was ingenious in solving the lateral thrusts at the end of such a series of vaults, notably with pre-stressed masonry edge beams cantilevered from the vault and carried by the same support or supports as the vault itself. Long spans are achieved in the longitudinal direc- tion of the vault through the performance of the entire vault as a beam that, for the same reason, can be an extensive cantilever. Acting as a beam introduces tensile bending stresses that are resolved by pre-stressing.

Dieste expressed special satisfaction in collaborating with the architects of the Growers' Pavilion, whose work can be seen, for example, in the variation of the vaults at both ends of the series.

Architects: Carlos Maximiliano Fayet and Claudio Araujo

PIA WT. C oio a

== ACA AA A کھو‎ o

fig. 87

fig. 86: View of the Growers’ Pavilion, from the northwest

fig. 87: Aerial view of the CEASA complex, which employs both self-supporting and Gaussian vault types

fig. 88: Growers’ Pavilion, partial longitudinal section, at northern end

fig. 88

fig. 89

CÍTRICOS CAPUTTO FRUIT PACKING PLANT

Salto, 1971-72, 1986-87

80

The principal space of this packing plant is a series of large discontinuous double-curvature vaults spanning approximately 150 feet. The illustrations of this work show well the light qualities of this vaulting system: the effective and pleasing lighting of the vaults seen in both directions, and the diffusion but also vivacity of light throughout the space.

The later dates of the project correspond to the construction of a cold storage facility with a continuous double-curvature vault. A characteristic Dieste water tower with a perforated shaft was also built nearby.

fig. 91

fig. 89: Transverse view, showing the array of lighting conditions

fig. 90:General view of the complex with the principal space of discontinuous double-curvature vaults in the distance

fig. 9E Work space during the off-season, lit by diffused and concen- trated light

[|

[d

IT

sad

TII

fig. 92

fig. 92: Impression of an almost-continuous light source, created by the curvature of the discontinuous vaults

fig. 93: Detail of vaults

fig. 94: Detail of vaults and windows

overleaf fig. 95: Varied color and texture of the ceramic units under the play of light

27

: >» i F y j p i i j F d n > à چ‎ j E į id ; | f y Ss , ۳ #

i

D s

fig. 96

LANAS TRINIDAD WOOL INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX

Trinidad, 1965, 1979, 1986-87, 1988-89

86

This complex was built in four stages using self-carrying vaults, such as appeared at a small scale at the Dieste house in 1961 Illustrated here is the third stage of Lanas Trinidad, with bays of 26 by 131 feet. The vaults are stable without beams or tympana; consequently, the structure is very light for

such a long span, and good lighting is achieved through change in the height of the vaults.

Architects: Lorieto and Queirolo

fig. 96:General interior view of the self-carrying vaults. At the right, the flat edge-beam and the column of altered shape receive the lateral thrust that elsewhere is balanced by adjoining vaults.

fig. 97: Drawing containing plan of reinforcing for one group of eight bays plus edge beams, transverse sections, and structural details of the edge beam and valleys

EHE |‏ لی CORTE GENERICO POR ARCO DE RIGIDEZ EN EL APOYO -‏ fig. 97‏

87

A 1‏ ا یں گا ES SANA XN A HN‏

NON

AN‏ ںی

کڪ

fig. 98

RIO METRO MAINTENANCE Subway trains are brought to this 560,000-square-foot facility for maintenance

HAN G AR and repair. The structural system employs self-carrying vaults and gains natu- ral light through both alternating heights and penetrations in the vaults. The engineering was done in the Montevideo office and construction was overseen by Dieste's partner, Eugenio Montañez, in Brazil.

Rio deJaneiro, 1971-79

88

* | MIU EE ETT TH t a

fig. 98: Self-carrying vaults, extending in both directions without loss of natural light fig. 99: Subway train, sheltered by cantilevered self-carrying vaults

89

fig. 100

MUNICIPAL BUS TERMINAL

Salto, 1973-74

90

Supported by a single row of columns are long self-carrying vaults with equal cantilevers of 40 feet. Such cantilever vaults are ideal for sheltering (as opposed to enclosing) structures and thus are perfect for bus stations. At the lateral outer edge of the vaults, Dieste sought a more gradual and spatial termination in consideration of people's passage through the space. H e did not adopt his most structurally efficient solution of a tapered edge beam but

rather an edge slab, the outer half of which is carried by athin, cantilevering concrete beam, separated from the central concrete outrigger by steel pins.

Collaborator: Architect Nestor Minutti

fig. 100: General view of the bus terminal, with its double-cantilevered self-carrying vaults fig. 101: The sheltering character of the vaults

fig. 101

o E 8 I A m سے‎ im ل‎

سے E‏ گے اکنا TE =‏ کس | 5 ACETUM. — ——— a1‏ n > pi ~ 1 p lm a E 3‏ ہے ا سے SE E‏ کش A‏

NU LA مد‎ DA TU WU» mo mA WE AA ° Efe

e CURVA DE INIRADOS DE BOVEDAS TEMA 1X

| [L]- ETT

—2. de th ! ھ٤‎ sá kim iF

=" oui in

re mE P

5777 a Y; E Sa A,

SS

d

SR

SS

venio abad‏ جا تاحد

© PLANTA ESCUÉMATICA FONDO DE VIGA

LP‏ — یھو

TATE

ARM,

fig. 103

92

ERN‏ = سے

Eo: و‎ orian — Iz.

fig. 104

fig. 102: Partial plan, sections, and details showing reinforcing and

pre-stressing steel. At upper right, plan and elevation

fig. 103: General view from the south

fig. 104: Special edge condition at the west

93

ELADIO DIESTE AS STRUCTURAL ARTIST John A. Ochsendorf

The discipline of structural engineering encompasses the design of structures that are efficient in their use of materials and economical in their methods of construction. In addition to the constraints of efficiency and economy, the best engineers seek to create forms that are elegant in their appearance. In his book The Tower and the Bridge, the structural engineering historian David Billington argues convincingly that the leaders in this field of design are "structural artists," who develop works of art through their pursuit of efficiency, economy, and elegance in construction.

Among the most admired structural artists are John A. Roebling (1806-1869), for his masterful long-span suspension bridges; Gustave Eiffel (1832-1923), for his elegant structures in iron; and Robert Maillart (1872-1940), for his pioneering forms in reinforced concrete. These designers succeeded primarily because they produced structures at a significantly lower cost than their competitors. Technically, they were working at the forefront of the profession, and they produced unprecedented works with minimum materials. Yet they were deeply concerned about the appearance of their designs and pursued dear structural expression as a guiding aesthetic principle. The constraints of economy led each to develop new forms, which are striking for their originality As artists, they criticized and refined their own works, developing clear personal styles.

To create works of structural art, the designer must know the construction process intimately. Roebling, Eiffel, and Maillart were responsible for their own companies, and they were often present on the construction sites of their projects. These designers produced structures at low cost because they mastered the construction process through years of experience in the field and sought suitable methods for dealing with local circumstances. Furthermore, each concentrated on one specific material and extended that material to impressive new applications by developing new methods of design and construction. For structural artists,

94

fig. 105: Rafael Guastavino, Jr., patent for reinforced ceramics illustrating metal reinforcing near the base and crown of the dome, 19 10 fig. 106: Influence of curvature in membranes: a) with curvature, and b) without curvature

the process of design is never disconnected from the process of construction.

Many leading structural artists began by constructing their works outside of the mainstream: Roebling, in the mid- western United States; Eiffel, in rural France; and Maillart, in remote regions of Switzerland. Initially their works were noteworthy only for their novelty, and the structures were not recognized for their aesthetic appeal. Widespread artistic recognition of these designers was not forthcoming in their lifetimes. Structural artists challenge the limits of design and construction and often fight a solitary battle to construct their unconventional works outside of the established methods.

Eladio Dieste (1917-2000) belongs to this pantheon of great structural artists. Just as Roebling pioneered with wire cable, Eiffel with iron, and Maillart with reinforced concrete, Dieste led the way in developing economical, efficient, and elegant structures in reinforced brick. Like his predecessors, he owned his own construction company and received com- missions primarily because he proposed the least expensive option. Dieste's detailed technical knowledge and extensive experience enabled him to extend vaulting in reinforced brick to a new scale. As with Roebling, Eiffel, and Maillart, he did not receive the recognition of critics for the aesthetic power of his work until very late in life.

1 DavwdP. Billington, The Tower and the Bridge The New Art of Structural Engineering (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1985).

2 Eladio Dieste, interview by Damián Bayón and Paolo Gasparini, The Changing Shape of Latin American Architecture Conversations with Ten Leading Architects (New York: John Wiley, 1979), 210-11

3 Ibid., 209-10.

4 Theengineer Marc Isambard Brunel (1769-1849) constructed with reinforced brick in England in the early nineteenth century. See Tom F. Peters, Building the Nineteenth Century (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1996), 66-70. Joseph Eugéne Anatole de Baudot (1834- 19 15) promoted reinforced masonry as a material of choice for architects in France during the late nineteenth century. See Kenneth Frampton, Studies in Tectonic Culture (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1995), 54-57.

5 For vaulting in France, see Turpin C. Bannister, "The Roussillon Vault:

Dieste designed according to the ideals of structural art, teking "jointly into account" the validity and efficiency from the structural point of view, the efficiency from the economic point of view, the efficiency in the conditioning of the spaces enclosed, and the aesthetic value, which for me, really, is a sort of ultimate summary, the ulti mate synthetical value judg- ment of all this series of factors.?

He was deeply critical of his own designs. In his con- cern for aesthetic values he searched for structural honesty, maintaining that "one thing that the spirit perceives about a form is the adequate or inadequate way in which it bears a load. In other words, the spirit is deeply sensitive to the fact of knowing if a form is completely successful from the structural point of view.”3 Like the best engineers, he sought elegant forms that expressed their structural function. By tracing the development of Dieste's career and examining his works alongside the designs of other leading structural artists, the accomplishments of this underappreciated figure will hopefully daim their rightful place in the context of engineering history.

The Development of Thin Shell Structures in Reinforced Brick Dieste's formation as a designer is directly linked to his use of reinforced brick as a structural system. Thus, it is worthwhile to trace the development of this system. Beginning in the nineteenth century, architects and engineers experi mented

The Apotheosis of a ‘Folk Construction," Journal of the Society of Architectural H istorians 27, no. 3(1968): 163-75. For Spanish vaulting, see Fray Lorenzo de San Nicolás, Arte y uso de arquitectura, 2 vols. (Madrid: Albatros, 1989), and Santiago Huerta, “The Mechanics of Timbrel Vaults: A Historical Outline,” in Between M athematics and Architecture, ed. Antonio Becchi et al. (Basel: Birkháuser, 2003). The term bóveda tabicada, or “tim- bre vault," is used in Spain, though the method is often called "Catalan vaulting" as well. See also Timothy P. Becker and Kent Anderson's essay on pages 202-07 of this volume.

6 GeorgeR. Collins, "The Transfer of Thin Masonry Vaulting from Spain to America," J ournal of the Society of Architectural H istorians 27, no. 3 (October 1968): 176-201 See also Janet Parks and Alan G. Neumann, eds., The Old World Builds the New: The Guastavino Company and the Technology of the Catalan Vault, 1885- 1962, exhib. cat. (New York:

fig. 106

with the concept of reinforced brick as a building material.4 In the twentieth century, lightly reinforced brick shells were inspired by timbrel vaulting, a common building method in the Mediterranean.» Rafael Guastavino (1842- 1908), upon emigrating to the United States from Catalonia in 1881, intro- duced the method with great success. His son, Rafael Guastavino, Jr. (1872-1950), continued constructing vaults

well into the twentieth century, and he appears to be the first to have introduced steel reinforcing to thin brick shells. In two patents, issued in 1910 and 1913, Guastavino, Jr. documented this system, which is a precursor to the thin shells of reinforced concrete developed widely in the ensuing decades (fig. 105). /

Two leading engineers explored methods of constructing thin shells in reinforced brick: Eduardo Torroja (1899-1961) in Spain and Eladio Dieste in Uruguay. Thin brick timbrel vaults of the type constructed by Guastavino played a role in the development of both engineers work.

Theleading figure in the Spanish school of thin shell vaulting, Torroja is most famous for demonstrating new possibilities in reinforced concrete? Yet he also recognized bricks as "adequate materials for shell structures, slabs, and membranes.”? He introduced steel reinforcing in the tradi- tional timbrel vault, designing reinforced brick shells as early as 1926. Openly acknowledging the influence of Catalan vaulting on his methods, Torroja wrote,

Columbia University, Avery Architectural Library and the Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Art Gallery, 1996); Santiago Huerta, ed., Las bóvedas de Guastavino en América, exhib. cat. (Madrid: Instituto Juan de Herrera, 2001). In his Essay on the Theory and H ¡story of Cohesive Construction, Applied Especially to the Timbrd Vault, Rafael Guastavino preferred the terms "timbrel vault," or "cohesive construction," to "Catalan vault." (Boston: Ticknor, 1893). See also Edward Allen's essay on pages 66-75 of this volume.

7 United States Patents 947,177 and 1052,142 were published along with Guastavinos other patents in the APT Bulletin: The Journal of Preservation Technology, special issue, Preserving H istoric Guastavino Tile Calings, Domes, and Vaults 30, no. 4 (1999): 59-156.

8 For a survey of the work of Eduardo Torroja, see the engineer's The Structures of Eduardo Torroja, 2nd ed. (Madrid: CEDEX, 2000), and José

95

fig. 107: Antoní Bonet, Berlingieri house, Punta Ballena, 1946-47 fig. 108: Eladio Dieste, vault solution for the Berlingieri house fig. 109: Eduardo Torroja, Church of Pont du Suert, Spain, 1955

The Catalonian brick vault is as typical of the region as the carob tree in its fields and just as marvelous. Modern theory finds it difficult to explain and measure the phenomenon of its resistance, and the builders who showed their genius in understanding [brick vaults] are dead and buried beneath the day which they used to make the brick centuries ago. The resistance of thin brick vaulting comes from the form of the vaulting, as the art historian George Collins described in his landmark discussion of Guastavino's construction methods. By creating curvature in the vault, a thin surface can resist forces as a membrane and will have a much higher resistance to loads than a thin surface without curvature. £ This can be illustrated by comparing the stiffness of a piece of paper with curvature to a piece of paper without curvature (fig. 106). As Dieste said in relation to thin shells,

The resistant virtues of the structures that we are searching

for depend on their form. It is because of their form that

they are stable, not because of an awkward accumulation

of matter....there is nothing more noble and elegant from

an intellectual viewpoint than resistance through form. B Thus, the curved piece of paper develops load capacity due to the form of the structure.

Dieste's link to timbrel vaulting is more tenuous and can be traced to the interest shown by modernists in traditional Catalan vaulting. At approximately the same time that Torroja began building shells in reinforced brick, modernist masters Le Corbusier (1887-1965) and Josep Lluis Sert (1902-1983) became interested in tile vaulting, largely through their expo- sure to the works of Antoni Gaudí (1852- 1926). The young Catalan architect Antoní Bonet (1913- 1989), who collaborated with Le Corbusier and Sert in the 1930s, brought with him a knowledge of timbrel vaulting methods when he emigrated to Argentina during the Spanish Civil War (1936-39). Bonet met Dieste in 1946, and Dieste's development is duein part to Bonet's earlier experience with timbrel vaulting in Catalonia. 4

In 1946, Bonet designed the Berlingieri house at the resort of Punta Ballena in Uruguay (fig. 107). While seeking local assistance on a structural problem posed by the barrel

96

fig. 107

vaulting for the house, Bonet met the young engineer Dieste, and their collaboration on this project led to Dieste's first application of reinforced brick. According to the German historian of construction Jos Tomlow, Dieste rejected Bonet's initial concept of a barrel vault with a reinforced concrete roof because the form was poor and overly expen- sive. H e suggested instead a wooden roof with tiles as a more rational solution, but Bonet disliked this idea. Dieste then suggested that the roof be vaulted in brick, and both agreed to pursue this option. Dieste suggested that thin bar- rel vaults of brick be reinforced so as to function as shell structures. Bonet described the Catalan vault to Dieste, who knew nothing of timbrel vaulting at this point, and both agreed to proceed.

Dieste descri bed his final solution of reinforced brick vaults in his 1947 article “Bóveda nervada de ladrillos “de espejo.” 16 It is significant that in this first project he chose to construct the vaults in a catenary form, so that the vault would function in pure compression under the vertical load of its own weight." Dieste was dearly thinking in terms of structural, rather than geometrical, forms; this choice of form allowed him to achieve a remarkable thinness of only 2 inches over a span of 20 feet (fig. 108). A geometrical form, such as a cylindrical barrel vault, would have required much more material and was therefore unsatisfactory to Dieste.

Antonio Fernández Ordóñez, Eduardo Torroja (Madrid: Ediciones Pronaos, 1999). See also Billington, The Tower and the Bridge, 183-93.

9 Fernandez, Eduardo Torroja, 30.

10 John Ochsendorf and Joaquín Antuña, "Eduardo Torroja and cerámica armada," in Proceedings of theFirst International Congress on Construction History, ed. Santiago Huerta (Madrid: Instituto Juan de Herrera, 2003), III: 1527-36. See also J osé María Cabeza Lainez and José Manuel Almodóvar Melendo, "Las bóvedas de cerámica armada en la obra de Eladio Dieste,” in Actas del tercero Congreso Nacional de H istoria dela Construcción, ed. Amparo Graciani Garcia (Madrid: Instituto Juan de Herrera, 2000), I: 135-42.

1 Torroja, Structures of Eduardo Torroja, 30. The great virtue of timbrel vaulting is that it can be built with no supporting formwork.

12 Collins, "Transfer of Thin Masonry Vaulting,” 176. See Huerta, “The Mechanics of Timbrel Vaults,” for an excellent discussion of the structural

"CONE TRANSVERSAL SOVEDA DISISPENTE

AA S__

fig. 108

Significantly, the exterior view of the completed Berlingieri house does not express the thinness of the struc- tural vault. Bonet's design called for an insulating space and an additional layer of roof tiles on top of the thin vault, resulting in a heaw appearance for the completed roof that obscures Dieste's elegant structural solution. For Dieste, expressing the thin structure was a priority in almost all of his later work. The Berlingieri house is a work of architectural art but not of structural art, and this illustrates the difference in aesthetic priorities between the engineer Dieste and the architect Bonet. Like other structural artists, Dieste preferred to expose the structure as an important aesthetic aim in constructi on, as may be seen in the exposed vault detail at the north elevation of his own house.

With the Berlingieri house, Dieste invented cerámica armada in South America. He went on to build shells of unprecedented scale in reinforced brick. Although Bonet descri bed the project as a rebirth of Catalan vaulting, Dieste distanced his system from that of unreinforced brick vault- ing. Dieste worked in the tradition of the structural engineer to create his thin shells in brick, using steel reinforcement to carry tensile stresses rather than in the ancient tradition of unreinforced timbrel vaulting, which creates shells whose forces act only in compression. The origin of Diestes work is more closely linked to thin shell concrete construction, known

behavior of unreinforced timbre vaults, which must act in pure compres- sion. Shells reinforced with steel are capable of resisting tension and can act as a membrane. The membrane theory, which assumes that the shell has no resistance to bending, can demonstrate the resistance of a curved shell by finding a pattern of membrane forces that are in equilibrium with the applied loads.

13 Eladio Dieste, “Architecture and Construction," 187 of this volume. Originally published as “Arquitectura y construcción,” in “Eladio Dieste, el Maestro del ladrillo," sp. no. Summa: Colección Summarios (Buenos Aires) 8, no. 45 (July 1980): 84-93

14 Jos Tomlow, “La bóveda tabicada y e nacimiento de la cerámica arma da," in Huerta, ed., Las bóvedas de Guastavino, 241-51

15 Ibid., 244-45.

16 Eladio Dieste, “Bóveda nervada de ladrillos ‘de espejo," Revista de

fig. 109

to him from his studies in civil engineering and his earlier design experience.20

Though few other South American engineers pursued reinforced brick as a structural material, Torroja applied it throughout his career. The ideas of Dieste and Torroja were strikingly similar. Both sought out inexpensive methods of construction to create elegant structural forms. Their efforts would culminate in the 1950s in the design and construction of small parish churches employing innovative structural sys- tems and similar construction methods. Remarkably, Torroja was nearing the end of his career, while Dieste was entering the early stages of his.

Torroja and Dieste: Structural Forms in Church Design Although best known for his designs in reinforced concrete, Torroja built elegant structures in reinforced brick.21 The construction of thin concrete shells requires the use of exten- sive formwork, which is costly to build, so Torroja employed reinforced brick as an economical alternative. Asked to design a church for the small town of Pont du Suert in the Pyrénées, he produced a unique structure in reinforced brick that incorporated double-curved surfaces (fig. 109).22 By repeating the curving form and leaning one against the other, the sur- faces serve as both walls and roof of the church. An affinity between this work and that of Dieste, as demonstrated in his

Ingeniería [Montevideo] 473 (Sept. 1947): 510-2.

17 A catenary is the shape taken by a cable hanging under its own weight. If this hanging cable is frozen and inverted, it gives the shape of an arch acting in pure compression. The English scientist Robert H ooke (1635- 1/03) proposed this idea in 1675: “As hangs the flexible line, so but inverted, will stand the rigid arch." For the source of this quotation, see Jacques Heyman, Structural Analysis: A Historical Approach (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 79.

18 The vault was constructed of a thickness of only one brick (about 2 inches). It has a rise of one sixth of the span (approximately 3feet). The thrust of the vault is resisted by steel ties spaced every 10 feet, so that the resultant load on the walls is purely vertical. See Tomlow, "La bóveda tabicada," and Dieste, “Bóveda nervada," for more complete descriptions of the system.

97

fig. 111

98

p

fig. 110: Eladio Dieste, Church of Christ the Worker, Atlántida, 1958-60 fig. 11 Church of Christ the Worker: a) transverse section, and b) moment diagram of a pinned frame due to self-weight

Church of Christ the Worker in Atlántida, is readily apparent. Intriguingly, Torroja designed the church— and a second, which similarly relies on reinforced brick—immediately upon his return from a tour of South America in early 1952, over twenty-five years after he first experimented with rei nforced brick shell construction.23

As Torroja designed the church of Pont du Suert, Dieste began work on the church in Atlántida. Like Torroja, Dieste's thinking as a structural engineer governed his archi- tectural concepts, and in his search for economy he created a new form. After years of study, Dieste completed the famed church in 1960 (fig. 110).

The walls of the church were built in reinforced brick without formwork by using an undulating surface to provide lateral stiffness. The walls begin in two parallel lines and rise upward in a ruled surface, following a series of parabolas in plan. The walls are topped with an edge beam in reinforced concrete that helps to transfer the load from the roof. The roof is made of a series of repeating brick vaults that contain steel reinforcement to reduce the thrust on the walls. The trans- verse section follows the moment diagram for a pin-supported portal frame under its own weight and therefore provides for an efficient use of material (fig. 19.24 Derived from purely structural considerations, this innovative solution clearly demonstrates the thinking of a structural artist.

Diestes church in Atlántida shares a number of simi- larities with Torrojas church in Pont du Suert. Both were constructed of thin shells of reinforced brick with the goal of producing a low-cost parish church in a structural form. Both churches use curving lateral walls to increase the structural stiffness and reduce the amount of material required. In addition, both engineers designed a separate bell tower in reinforced masonry. The overall projects have the same scale.25 Finally, both churches incorporate sections of glass inserted in the brick to admit natural lighting. Significant dif- ferences exist between the works as well. In Torroja's church, the walls curve inward to become the roof, while in the Atlántida church the roof vaults and walls are visually separat- ed. Unlike Torroja's freestanding construction method,

Dieste's method required formwork to create the roof vaults of his church. While Torroja hides the construction method by covering the brick with plaster on the inside and stone on the outside, Dieste leaves the brick exposed. Overall, Dieste worked under much stricter economical constraints, and he produced a more innovative structure as a result.26

As a work of structure, Dieste’s Atlántida church is superior to Torrojas Pont du Suert church. Dieste's work cost less, used less material, and is more visually striking in its final form. In particular, Dieste illustrated the structural effi- ciency of a thin membrane by exposing the edges of the brick shell. This expression of edge thinness is a characteristic of structural art in reinforced concrete shells by Maillart, Felix Candela (1910-1997), Heinz Isler (b. 1926), and other mas- ters.27 Torrojas church at Pont du Suert is not as expressi ve, and his structure is more of a curiosity than a work of art.

The structural artist always seeks to express the struc- tural function of the elements as clearly as possible. This is exemplified by comparing the bell towers at Atlántida and Pont du Suert. Torroja's tower narrows at the base, and the tapered form does not express the load-carrying function of the tower. Dieste illustrates the flow of gravity loads in his tower with vertical columns in brick. H e explained,

Coherence between the appearance of the form and the con-

structed reality is also important. Coherence makes the form

19 Tomlow, "La bóveda tabicada," quoting a conversation with Dieste, 247. 20 Seeibid., and Remo Pedreschi, Eladio Dieste (London: Thomas Telford, 2000), for more on Dieste's education.

21 Torroja, Structures of Eduardo Torroja, and Billington, The Tower and the Bridge, 183-93

22 For more on this project, see Fernández, Eduardo Torroja, 152-59.

23 Torrojas renewed interest in reinforced brick may have been directly inspired by Dieste. For one month in early 1952, Torroja traveled through- out Argentina, Chile, Peru, and Colombia. While Torroja does not seem to have visited Uruguay or me Dieste personally, there is a strong possibility that he learned of the engineer's early work during his traves. A recent dis- sertation on Torroja mentions this possibility, although further research will be required to substantiate this claim. See Joaquin Antuña Bernardo, "Las estructuras de edificación de Eduardo Torroja Miret” (Ph.D. diss.,

intelligible to us. In the Maldonado television tower. . . the horizontal elements were placed in a discontinuous manner. The alternative solution, which was the first that occurred to us, was much simpler. This solution would make a ring from each group of horizontal elements. ... With much effort, | realized that the rings would divide the surface of the discon- tinuous shell that was the tower; they would not have been expressively appropriate to the structural unity of the surface.28 By emphasizing the vertical load-bearing system in the tower, Dieste reveals the importance of structural expression in his built works. Both solutions would cost approximately the same and would use the same amount of material, but in staggering the horizontal elements Dieste made a conscious aesthetic decision that would better illustrate the flow of forces in the tower. H ere Dieste speaks the language of the structural artist: “Form is a language, and this language should be intel- ligible to us.”29 From the very beginning of his career, Dieste showed an affinity for structural forms and a desire to express these forms clearly. With the Atlántida church, Dieste began to explore the possibilities of cerámica armada. He went on to set new precedents in reinforced brick vaulting. By comparing Dieste's work to pioneering structures in reinforced concrete, the design philosophy of this structural artist can be further illuminated. |n particular, the reinforced concrete shells of

Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, 2002), 191 Torroja experimented with reinforced brick as early as 1925 in the construction of bridge caissons. See J ohn Ochsendorf and Joaquín Antuña, "Eduardo Torroja and cerámica armada,” in Huerta, ed., Proceedings, 111: 1527-36.

24 Pedreschi, Eladio Dieste, 67.

25 The church in Pont du Suert measures 43 feet by 108 feet in plan, and the church in Atlántida measures approximately 50 feet by 100 feet. 26 Pedreschi, Eladio Dieste, 67. Billington notes that greater economical constraints generally lead to greater originality and to better works of structural art. See Billington, TheTower and the Bridge, 210- 11

27 Billington, TheTower and the Bridge, 190-92.

28 Eladio Dieste, "Awareness of Form," 191-192 of this volume.

99

fig. 112: Eugene Freyssinet, railway repair shop, Paris, 1927

fig. 113: Eladio Dieste, Cítricos Caputto Plant, Salto, 1971-72

fig. 114: Robert Maillart, Cement Hall, Swiss National Exhibition, Zurich, 1939, under construction

fig. 115: Eladio Dieste, Massaro Agroindustries, Joanicó, Canelones, 1976-80

Eugene Freyssinet, Maillart, and Isler illustrate a similar search for new structural forms and provide a context

for judging the historical importance of Dieste's work as a structural engineer.

Freyssinet and Dieste: Thin Shells and Steel Ties

French engineer Eugene Freyssinet (1879-1962) was a mas- ter of construction, and he described himself and his people as universal artisans. By becoming a builder, he advanced his goal of creating a society with "an extreme concern for the simplification of forms and economy of means." 3 | n the first half of the twentieth century, Freyssinet developed the concept of pre-stressed concrete, his greatest contribution to the construction world. Early in his career, he designed in reinforced concrete and completed two major projects show- ing new possibilities for thin shell structures. The first work was a pair of large dirigible hangars at Orly in France, which became known around the world upon their completion in 1921 The second work, less well known, was a railway repair shop at Bagneux, near Paris, completed in 1927 (fig. 112). Both works demonstrate an affinity with later shells by Dieste, the latter design being particularly relevant.

For the railway repair shop, Freyssinet used a series of small conoid shells supported on thin columns to create a large space, open in feeling. Thethrust of the vaults is resisted by a series of tension ties. Looking in one direction, the structure appears almost transparent, while looking in the opposite direction, the shells appear solid. The construction of these shells was made economical through the reuse of formwork from bay to bay.

Dieste designed many buildings in forms similar to Freyssinet's at Bagneux. His packing plant for Cítricos Caputto, completed in 1972, serves as a typical example (fig. 113). H ere, brick vaults span 148 feet without the support of internal columns. Steel tension ties resist the thrust of the vaults, and glazing admits light between the repeating shells. The brick shells act as an arch, and the undulating cross section pro- vides resistance to asymmetrical loading and to buckling. By combining catenary forms in a smooth shell, Dieste produced

100

structural shapes that allowed him to span great distances with minimum material.

The external views of these shells by Freyssinet and Dieste are not as expressive as their interior views, which are striking in light of their minimalism. Both designers incorporated repeating forms in order to economize on construction costs, while they used different structural ideas to generate shell shapes. Freyssinet used the conoids, a geometric form, and Dieste used the catenary, a structural form, but both conceived the overall problem as one of arches rather than of freestanding shells—that is, of struc- tural forms acting primarily in two dimensions rather than in three—and called upon steel ties to restrain the thrust of these arches.

Like other leading engineers, Dieste tried to avoid using unnecessary ti e-rods and stiffening beams that did not integrate visually with the thin structural shells.22 | ndeed, he used fewer ties per bay in his Cítricos Caputto Plant than did Freyssinet in his railway repair shop. The aesthetic impact of both Freyssinet's and Dieste's shells is compromised by the use of numerous steel ties on the interior.2 | n later works, such as the Don Bosco school gymnasium of 1983, Dieste obscured the steel ties in order to reduce the visual clutter. He was constantly looking to refine his solutions to achieve greater structural integration.

Maillart and Dieste: The Vault as a Cantilever Beam

While Freyssinet turned his primary focus to pre-stressed concrete by 1930, other engineers continued to advance the construction of thin shells in reinforced concrete during the subsequent decade. The Swiss engineer Robert Maillart led the way. Maillart was the first great structural artist to work in reinforced concrete; best known for his bridges, he also produced a series of structures with stunning and innovative roof forms in the material.+ The engineering establishment often rejected his unorthodox and original forms because they could not be analyzed by conventional methods, but in his design philosophy, Maillart exemplified the goals, and the difficulties, of the structural artist.

For the 1939 Swiss National Exhibition in Zurich, Maillart designed the Cement Hall, a thin shell vault of purely structural form (fig. 14). In his Space, Time, and Architecture, Sigfried Giedion recognized that "in the hands of a great engineer, this pavilion, conceived only to combine strength and the utmost lightness, became at once a work of art." The structure is both expressi ve and integrated. The thin shell of the vault is fully exposed, yet the vault could not stand without the accompanying structural elements. The lateral thrust of the vault is resisted by the horizontal slabs, and the central walkway acts as a tension tie. The arch ribs stiffen the vault over the central supports, and the vault acts as a cantilever beam in the longitudinal direction, with bending resistance provided by the vault's great depth. Each element is necessary, and thus Maillart reduced the structure to a remarkable thin- ness. This is the work of a mature structural artist, completed when Maillart was sixty-seven years old; it was one of the final projects in his impressive career. The Cement Hall was destroyed after the 1939 fair, but its legacy has been perpetuated by the popularity of Giedion's seminal work, which recognized the aesthetic potential of engineering structures.

It is possible that Dieste was familiar with this integrated structural form by Maillart, although he does not refer to the Zurich Cement Hall in his writings. Regardless, one of Diestes most prominent structural devices—the post-tensi oned

29 Ibid., 192 of this volume.

30 In his essay “La invención inevitable," Dieste wrote, “Freyssinet daimed that he never learned more from anyone than he did from the arti- sans who maintained his grandmother's windmill once a year." Published as “The Inevitable Invention," in Antonio Jiménez Torrecillas, ed., Eladio Dieste: 1943-1996, trans. Michael Maloy and Harold David Kornegay (Seville: Consejería de Obras Públicas y Transportes, 1996), 246. Published as "La invención inevitable" Summa: Colección Temática (Buenos Aires) 19 (June 1987): 43-47, and, in part, in "La inevitable invención tecnológica," Summa: Colección Summarios (Buenos Aires) 8, no. 45 (July 1980): 93-95. 31 Eugene Freyssinet, “Freyssinet by Himself," in A H alf-Century of French Prestressing Technology, special English ed., Travaux 50 (April-May 1966): 18. 32 Two of the most prolific engineers in thin concrete shells, Felix Candela and Heinz Isler, both sought to eliminate stiffening beams as well as exposed

fig. 115

cantilever vault—is based on very similar ¡deas.37 Beginning

in the 1960s, he designed a series of such vaults for structures ranging from factories to bus stations to train terminals. Diestes project for Massaro Agroindustries in rural Uruguay, completed in 1978, provides an elegant example of this form (fig. 115). The double-cantilevered vaults at the north front of this warehouse are comparable structurally to Maillart's vault for the Cement H all.

Like Maillart's thin shell, Dieste's structure is a barrel vault that acts as both a thin shell and a cantilever beam. At each end, the thrust of the vault is resisted by a tapered hori- zontal edge beam supported on a diagonally-braced reinforced concrete column. Both designers reduced the area of the slabs to make the horizontal beam more efficient: Maillart, by opening circular holes in the slabs; and Dieste, by tapering the horizontal slab to a minimum at the end of the cantilever. Overall, both designers used structural forms for the vault: Dieste's vaults take a catenary form in cross section, while Maillart's vault resembles a parabola, which narrows toward the end of the cantilever.

Although these shells function in a similar way, significant structural differences also exist. Dieste used post- tensioning in his shells, which allowed him to cantilever 54 feet with a relatively small rise in the shells. Maillart used a much deeper vault to span roughly the same distance in

tension ties in their designs. See Billington, The Tower and the Bridge, 208. 33 Billington argues that shell structures with steel ties do not express an integration of form, and he has descri bed the effect as "a disquieting maze of thin linear elements hovering beneath the smooth surfaces of shell and glass." Ibid., 207.

34 For a comprehensive survey of Maillart's work, see David P. Billington, Robert M aillart: Builder, D esigner, Artist (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997).

35 Sigfried Giedion, Space Time, and Architecture, 5h ed. (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1967), 473.

36 Ibid., 463-73 See Billington, Robert M aillart, 234-42, for a discussion of the historical importance of the Cement H all.

37 Dieste called them autoportantes, or self-supporting vaults. Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 89-145. The German engineer Rainer Barthel has noted

101

reinforced concrete. Dieste's use of post-tensioning and the smaller scale of his shells allowed him to avoid the heavy rib arches that Maillart required on the outer surface of his shell. Maillart minimalized column size by using the horizontal walkway to reduce the horizontal force on the columns. By contrast, Dieste relied on the exterior columns to resist the lat- eral forces and therefore required heavier structural elements, including an inclined supporting member to carry the thrust of the vaults to the foundations. The abrupt junction between the visually powerful shell and the minimal exterior column may be considered a minor aesthetic flaw in Diestes work. The shell and the column have important structural functions, but they are not visually integrated. |n the Cement Hall, Maillart reduced the complex forces from the vault to four small hinges at the foundations, and his columns are more carefully integrated within the overall form.

While aesthetic ideas governed the final design deci- sions made by both Maillart and Dieste, these ideas never violated the engineers’ technical goals. As Jiménez Torrecillas wrote, “Only the essential finds a place in Dieste's work" 9; this statement applies to the work of Maillart as well, and to that of the best engineers in the Swiss tradition, who labor to derive elegant new forms from purely structural requirements.

Isler and Dieste: New Shell Forms In the tradition of Swiss engineering excellence, Heinz Isler has designed some of the most striking thin shells in rein- forced concrete of the second half of the twentieth century. He creates thin shells by hanging small membranes in tension and creating smooth curving surfaces that are then inverted and scaled up to create large-scale structures in compression. Like other leading structural artists, | sler owns his own design office and works closely with a local builder to produce economical forms. Within the constraint of economy, he discovered new forms from purely structural considera- tions and demonstrated the unlimited possibilities for thin compression shells to be found in hanging models.

A typical example of Isler's surprising forms can be seen in the Heimberg Tennis Center, completed in Switzerland in

102

fig. 116: Heinz Isler, Heimberg Tennis Center, Switzerland, 1979 fig. 117: Eladio Dieste, CADYL horizontal silo, Young, 1976-78

1979 (fig. 116). This thin-shell reinforced concrete roof is made up of four repeating vaults, each spanning 154 feet. The form of the vaults is derived from hanging membrane models, so that the shells act in pure compression under dead load. Through experimentation, Isler developed a form, providing the necessary stiffening at its upturned edges and preventing any danger of buckling in thethin shell. As Billington notes, these are not "the beaux-arts spaces of high architecture built in spite of cost and the nature of materials; rather, they are only built because they reorder materials in new ways and at low costs." 40

Dieste and Isler solved similar problems with similar forms. Billington's description of Isler's vaults also applies to the thin shells designed by Dieste, whose large horizontal silos echo the form of Isles buildings. One year before the opening of the Heimberg Tennis Center, Dieste completed a horizontal silo for CADYL, an agricultural cooperative in Young (fig. 17).^! This large-scale shell in reinforced brick rep- resents another example of the economical forms developed by Dieste to solve structural problems. To cover a large area and resist the lateral thrust of the grain stored inside, Dieste designed an undulating vault spanning 95 feet. The cross section of the horizontal silo is a catenary, the shape of a hanging chain, so that like | sler's shells, the vault will func tion in pure compression under the vertical load of its own weight. By undulating the shell, Dieste increased the stiffness of the membrane and decreased the amount of material necessary. Finally, like | sler, Dieste designed the vault to be constructed economically by constructing one bay at a time using movable formwork.42 After completing this project, Dieste went on to build a number of larger structures using the same system, such as the 1997 silo in Nueva Palmira, which spans 148 feet.43

The principal difference between Isler's tennis center and Dieste's horizontal silo designs is the type of loading, and it is interesting to note how each engineer shaped their form in response to this consideration. | n the case of Isler's shells, the dominant load is vertical and therefore the form of the structure is governed by the vertical loading. For Dieste's silo,

the dominant load is horizontal — created by the thrust of the grain on the inside of the silo, which must be resisted by the walls.44 To solve this problem, Dieste began with the appropri- ate form for controlling vertical loads, the catenary, and added aseries of undulations to stiffen the walls against the lateral thrust of the grain. The greater number of undulations in the shell of Dieste is justified by its structural requirements. Isler's thin shells have a larger span but the loading is not as severe, and their form reflects this fact. While Isler derives his structural shapes from three-di mensional experiments, Dieste assumes two-di mensional arch behavior, following the simpler form of the catenary. | n the case of a shell supported on cor- ners, Isler’s three-dimensional approach is appropriate; for the continuous foundation support of the horizontal silo, Dieste's two-di mensional approach is also appropriate. Both forms are deri ved from structural principles, their aesthetic ideas shaped purely by structural needs. |n his essay “Architecture and Construction,” Dieste descri bed himself as an engineer who “found in the process of building warehouses, he was creating architecture, even though that was not his object. H e also found that he had an awareness of form and in confronting this awareness, he discovered that it helped him to solve prob- lems that were strictly structural."45

the similarities between the concrete shell structure by Maillart and the cantilevered shells by Dieste. Rainer Barthel, Eladio Dieste Form und Konstruktion (Munich: Lehrstuhl für H ochbaustatik und Tragwerksplanung, Technische Universitat München, 2001), 29.

38 Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 15.

39 SeeJohn Chilton, H anz Isler (London: Thomas Telford, 2000); Billington, The Tower and the Bridge, 222- 32; and David Billington, The Art of Structural Design: A Swiss Legacy (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton Art Museum, 2003), 228-62.

40 Billington, The Tower and the Bridge, 231

41 Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 70

42 Freyssinet pioneered this method of construction in the Orly hangars of 1921 See José Antonio Fernández Ordóñez, Eugene Freyssinet (Barcelona: 2c Ediciones, 1978), 30.

The Future of Brick Vaulting

Dieste discovered new methods to solve “strictly structural” problems and in the process, developed his own aesthetic ideas and artistic style. Dieste's solution is closely linked to the use of cerámica armada and suggests that contemporary engi- neers have neglected a viable construction material in brick. By exploiting the structural potential of brick, Dieste demon- strated by extension the vast and as ye unrealized possibilities for using traditional materials in conjunction with modern engineering methods. Diestes work raises the question, what is the value of brick in construction?

Dieste believed that brick was superior to other construction materials, and argued for its use for numerous technical reasons.48 |n comparison to reinforced concrete for thin shell construction, he advocated the use of brick for the following four reasons: Brick weighs less than concrete, reducing the cost of the supporting structure during construction. Brick is easier than concreteto shapeinto double-curvature vaults. In a brick vault, the vast majority of the material is already dry and the small amount of mortar sets quickly, allowing the forms to be stripped earlier.47 The dry brick absorbs moisture, speeding up the setting of the concrete mortar. Brick construction uses less cement.

43 Pedreschi, Eladio Dieste, 60-62.

44 Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 70.

45 Eladio Dieste, “Architecture and Construction," 182 of this volume. Originally published as “Arquitectura y construcción,” in “Eladio Dieste, el maestro del ladrillo,” sp. no., Summa: Colección Summarios (Buenos Aires) 8, no. 45 (July 1980).

46 For a complete list of reasons, see Eladio Dieste, "La cerámica arma- da,” in Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 34-36. Originally published as Eladio Dieste, “Acerca de la cerámica armada,” Summa (Buenos Aires) 70 (Dec. 1973), 45.

47 Formwork can be stripped in a matter of hours in brick construction, compared to days for formwork used in reinforced concrete construction. Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 46-47.

48 Dieste addressed the appropriateness of technology in several essays.

103

An additional benefit, not mentioned by Dieste, regards the compressi ve stresses in a well-designed shell, which are relatively low compared to the strength of brick or concrete; provided that an appropriate structural form is used, brick provides a suitable material for thin shell construction.

Dieste's work reveals new possibilities for brick in vaulting, but significant barriers continue to prevent the widespread use of this material as a structural component. The construction industry in North America lacks expertise and experience with brick as a structural material, particularly in vaulting applications. Furthermore, few engineers are trained to work in structural masonry, and codified calculation methods are unsatisfactory. Finally, large companies look for general solutions to construction problems and do not encourage local solutions, which depend on local expertise.

Dieste personally devised ways around each of these problems. H e directed and trained a generation of workers in the construction of brick structures. H e worked outside of conventional regulations and developed his own design methods to demonstrate the safety of thin shells constructed in brick. H e pursued practice locally and remained personally responsible for the work. To apply brick vaulting in the future, designers can follow Dieste's example to overcome similar obstacles.

The Ecological Engineer If Eladio Dieste ably represents the structural artist of the past, he also provides a glimpse of the engineer of the future. Structural artists have always seen themselves as public servants, building public works that are both affordable and beautiful, but Dieste took this concept further. For Dieste, a work of technology must answer a series of pointed questions: Does the solution use local resources? Is it just? Is it ecologi- cally sensitive?48 Dieste built not only elegant structural forms but ones that considered the local community, the environment, and the wider social implications involved in their construction.

As engineers and architects move toward methods of sustainable building, the lessons of structural art are

104

particularly relevant. Most importantly, the ideals of engineering should not oppose the protection of the environment and the efficient use of natural resources. Sustainable building requires local methods and materials, and structural art is a local practice of construction; as Billington summarized: "such designs depend upon their designers first-hand experience

in the field.... There is no such thing as an international style of structural art; its integrity depends upon its integration into local building practice.”49

The final works by Dieste, a series of structures in Alcalá de Henares in Spain, illustrate Billington's point; when Spanish architects imported his construction system in the 1990s, inexperience led to numerous problems in construction. Without local expertise to oversee construction, the system failed.% Like structural art, ecologically responsible structural design is most successful when created by engineers and craftsmen with local circumstances in mind.

Dieste's life and work offer three important lessons for designers and educators, the first being that understanding the construction process is crucial to creating exceptional works of structure. All structural artists are builders as well as designers. Secondly, Dieste's work demonstrates the possibility of constructing with a combination of traditional materials, such as brick, and high-strength industrial materials, such as steel. Structural experimentation, particularly with locally

See Dieste, "La inevitable invención tecnológica," in "Eladio Dieste, el mae- stro del ladrillo," 93-95; and "Technology and Underdevelopment” in Jiménez, ed., Eladio Dieste, 259-66. Originally published as "Técnica y sub- desarrollo," CEDA: Revista del Centro de Estudiantes de Arquitectura, Montevideo 34 (Feb. 1973): 1-5. See also Dieste's "Art, People, Technocracy” 194-97 of this volume.

49 Billington, TheTower and the Bridge, 268-69.

50 A series of three Spanish churches were built between 1996 and 1997; they are near replicas of Dieste's famous earlier churches. See Pedreschi, Eladio Dieste, 122-39. The Spanish churches experienced serious problems with water penetration.

produced materials, should be encouraged. Finally, Diestes success illustrates that good design must be adapted to local conditions.

As designers look to a future of increasing populations and decreasing natural resources, they would benefit from adopting new role models in design and construction. The ecological engineer must work together with the architect to solve the problems of limited resources through intelligent design. As an engineer, Dieste addressed the great challenge of the future to create economical, efficient, and elegant structures in an ecologically and socially responsible manner. His life and career serve as a valuable example for engineers and architects alike.

The author would like to thank Joaquín Antuña Bernardo, Jos Tomlow, Santiago H uerta Fernández, Fernando Pérez Oyarzun, David Billington, and Heinz Isler for their assistance, as well as the J. William Fulbright Scholarship Board for providing funds for a year of research in Spain.

fig. 118

"SEA GULL"

(Barbiere and Leggire Service Station), Salto, 1976

106

Zee M | "ii Aa NL ci iaa

00 انا - :سکب‎ x

hee re

This brick canopy carried on a single support is one of the best-known and most remarkable of Dieste's structures. While based on Dieste's self-carrying vaults, it is not properly a vault: it is effectively two counterbalanced wings. Thanks to a heavier section, reinforcing in the valley, and pre-stressing in the long dimension, the entire construction acts as a cantilever beam. This elegant work moves away from structural rationalism. At the same time, however, the canopy with centralized support provided the most effective form of protection at the gas pumps of a service station it originally served.

So distinctive and beloved was this work that when threatened with destruction in 1996, the mayor of Salto stepped in to save it. Transported to the south entrance of Salto (Puerta de la Sabiduría), the "Sea Gull" (as it was nicknamed) now serves as a greeting to the city and as a memorial to Eladio Dieste. The mayor's action was especially appropriate as Salto gave Dieste more commissions than any other city, with the exception of Montevideo, and Dieste responded with some of his best works.

fig. 119

LL TTL

ALLLLLLLILELLBAL.

fig. 120

fig. 118: The "Sea Gull," in its original location and performing its e intended use. The cantilevered self-carrying vaults at the left are | also by Dieste y Montañez.

fig. 119: The "Sea Gull" in its new installation as a formal welcome to the city. In the distance, vaults and water tower of Refresco del Norte, by Dieste

fig. 220: Drawings of the "Sea Gull" in plan and section. Note the reinforcing and pre-stressing details on the plan and half-section

fig. DE The remarkable coverage of the "Sea Gull"— 18 by 56 feet

fig. 121

107

Ee m ee وس‎ - ~ . pe = ` =- —- ee v سے‎ en x Se “س‎

~

ye

E e £ - d dí ve | Í MEN Bat CES الو یف ری‎ Pu کی رت و‎

و

AYU I PARADOR A summer café on the banks of the Uruguay River in Salto, the Ayuí parador represents another atypical structure in Dieste's oeuvre. The truncated cone of single-brick thickness covering a 49-foot diameter enclosure has a 10-foot cantilevered “brim.” The structure is ingeniously self-pre-stressed, as the deflection of the cantilever eliminates the need for an edge beam with heavy supports. The roof is carried on 24 very light columns— 1 Y 8-inch square folded sheet-metal tubes that also act as glazing mullions.

Salto, 1976-77

Coll abor ator: Architect Nestor Minutti

fig. 122: General view of the lightly supported conical brick vault of the Ayuí parador

108

fig. 123

CADYL HORIZONTAL SILO

Young, 1976-78

Dieste's horizontal silos, from those for Fosfato Thomas in Montevideo of 1965 to the largest at Nueva Palmira of 1996, are formed by continuous double- curvature vaults. Dieste indicated that buckling and wind loads were not critical in these structures, but the double-curvature in the lower part of the vaults was calculated to resist any outward thrust of a heaw loading of stored materials. The lateral thrust of the vault itself is resisted by pilings.

The silo at Young has a span of 99 feet, an area of 39,000 square feet, and a Capacity of 30,000 tons. Grain is supplied by mechanical feeds at the top and withdrawn at the bottom.

fig. 223: General view of the silo

109

fig. 124: Transverse section and foundation details

fig. 125: The silo in construction. At the far left, a completed section of the vault; from the left to the center, completed brick vaults without the cement covering; at the right, the large movable form in the process of being relocated. Note the small sticks on the surface of the form to locate precisely the bricks and reinforcing.

fig. 126: Concrete foundation and the springing of the vaults

fig. 127: General interior view, after having been given a flat floor

DETALLES DE FUNDACIONES. CORTE TRANSVERSAL MIRANDO A LIMPIEZA. ہہ‎ a ARA mE 20

esc. 150. 7 a \ Y پت‎

&

A

AL

A IA S m ` ESSA A d =

SF e IC

fig. 124

i=

a ORME

fig. 126

fig. 128

MASSARO AGROINDUSTRIES

J oanicó, Canelones, 1976-80

In their lightness and spatial organization, the self-carrying vaults at Massaro Agroindustries create one of the most dramatic effects of Dieste's many con- structions. The main working space of the approximately 97,000-square-foot warehouse is covered in five bays. Each 42-foot-wide bay is comprised of two double-canti lever self-carrying vaults, with columns spaced 115 feet apart. In the three central bays, the north and south vaults stop short of one another, admitting light to the center of the space. To the north, the main working area ends in 54-foot cantilevers that overlap another set of lower self-carrying vaults of the same width. The lower vaults, 82 feet long, are carried on a single row of columns. These vaults end in concave and convex cantilevers, placing their centers of gravity off center, as then are the columns.

As with most of Dieste's buildings, the plan of Massaro is very simple; itis the quality of space and light that he creates with his vaults that sets his work apart. H ere, the magnitude of the cantilevers, the sparseness of supports, and the thinness of the vaults create the drama of the grouping.

fig. 129

fig. 128:

fig. 129: fig. 130:

General view from the northwest, with the water tower also by Dieste

Spatial and light qualities under the three central bays Longitudinal section and transverse section of the main working space; north and west elevations

CONTE A=

FACHADA OESTE 8 ای‎

fig. 0

114

fig. BL View of the interior from the southerly main vaults, past the sky- light between the meeting of the north and south vaults, and on to the lower entry vaults

fig. 132: View from the central main vault to the lower entry vaults

fig. 133: Overlapping sets of vaults

fig. 134: The remarkable thinness of the vaults

fig. 132

fig. 133 fig. 134

CORTE APOYO 8y4

jo! i area as OT eT ACARTELAMIENTO NUAL | | سس سے‎ E سے ہا پا‎ eee سے‎ acevo. LL QUE EH PLANO t-f E 2 E 9 = ; ہے‎ : 1. 43 i EL a RN | FA fi/ A | A Re 7 [s q A zi PY [J| ABE Fi il Li T] PA 1 3 df! il. f/i J] MIA ; O a | حم ملا‎ ak d. سس‎ Po) 2ہ‎ ES جع‎ Eum Jay" 1 L1 | [— e سد‎ E ll 1 | 1 | |g | 11 | | Y | | i | | | ا‎ A + sli [ i} | — 7بت‎ è y 2 1 oy - yos او‎ oc i; jl y | d dv 4 3 "E I i | 1] | 1] )37 it tgs | E AL 3] fs تی‎ 34] [|l [9 3. | — 1j Bet ص‎ مم‎ | il^ 2000 7 zi D. d A i A HHH j Fiamma == EIS E $ ‘mea wei E 0 Pri Para وت‎ DADO Y PILOTES UAL QUE EN no.

E‏ یسیا LIN‏ سا ا e‏ ATT E i‏ == - پت CHRIS e‏ HA‏ 8ھ REO Eliis,‏ کس رھت E‏ fig. 135‏ | gl‏ | | j‏ حر ہل E‏ m‏ ' 1 7 | d‏ ۱ b‏ ; j 1 1‏ tooo‏ 1 | ! = =+ -+ | + F |‏ | | ۱ ےجس A | |‏ PRI |‏ 1 = a‏ t‏ : سا SAMMIMII ol‏ و ك is =‏ ا = ۱ X‏ | — او B‏ fig. 136‏

fig. 137

fig. 135: Transverse section of one of the extremely thin main vaults, with its outward lateral thrust restrained by an edge beam

fig. 136: Plan of the complex

fig. 137: View from under the cantilever of a main vault to the double-cantilever self-carrying vault with edge beam of the entry group

overleaf fig. 138: Overlapping sets of vaults

117

fig. 139

REFRESCOS DEL NORTE

Salto, 1977-80

120

Like Massaro Agroindustries, Refrescos del Norte is another complex that employs self-carrying vaults, though it is much smaller and is enclosed. Originally a cola bottling plant, it incorporates more self-conscious architectural details, as it provides office facilities and was intended to receive the public

as visitors. Most interesting is the entrance pavilion of double-cantilever self- carrying vaults supported on a row of three columns.

Coll abor ator: Architect Nestor Minutti

ru È HR ار لاو کڪ‎ Jo یں و‎ > 1 > TE A SM E ah e کا ای‎ T p = ' = » 1 ۱ D Wero Ty - س‎ E

E T xu t

- سام 1 0 = :

AEB hae at کرو‎

9b VET TREE‏ ایی MEI NU MP‏

fig. 139: General view from the northwest

fig. 140: Entrance pavilion of double-cantilever self-carrying vaults with an edge beam

fig. I Cantilevered self-carrying vaults at a loading area outside the production facility

121

fig. 144

fig. 142: Office and reception area, with a view of the inclined columns and edge beam that absorb the lateral thrust of the vaults

fig. 143: Interior of the production area, looking away from the loading area

fig. 144: Public reception area on the upper floor, showing the independence of the walls from the vault

23

Bs; Me اکا‎ =S E ۰ اکا‎ am

LETAN E E A ee î aî il A A E AE A A A p mM ERE E mum mmm سا‎ UR UR NF RI | EG NA EE EZ ہبتں۔د ہب‎ E ıı EDD ES = B "deir E | ے‎ | sss há 477]. — MI A | E 1 miu | us e | : . a J [ | La

fig. 145

SAN AGUSTÍN PARISH CENTER AND GYMNASIUM

M ontevi deo, 1978-80

124

Many of the works of Dieste y Montañez are of elemental construction and for simple programs, as with this work. The gymnasium for the parish of San Agustín is a single self-carrying vault with a span of 43 feet. Lateral thrusts are restrained by edge beams, one of which is extended into an entrance canopy. The minimal supports required by such vaults allow continuity of the win- dows, or of the